Birdingonthe.Net

Recent Postings from
The Arizona-New Mexico Birding List

> Home > Mail
> Alerts

Updated on Saturday, November 7 at 03:38 PM ET
The most recently received Mail is at the top.


Yellow-throated Warbler,©Barry Kent Mackay

7 Nov se AZ: Tucson - more Desert Museum notes [Andrew Core ]
7 Nov test [Carolyn Pitts ]
7 Nov AZ: Worm-eating Warbler photos [John Yerger ]
7 Nov seaz-Spirit Tree Inn Patagonia Az [Spirit Tree Inn B & B ]
7 Nov Re: Dates - an apology and my final word on the issue [Richard Ditch ]
7 Nov Re: Dates - an apology and my final word on the issue [Edward Boyd ]
7 Nov FWD: Flagstaff White-throated Sparrow [Moez Ali ]
7 Nov AZ: Ft. Lowell Park MAGNOLIA WARBLER continues [David Stejskal ]
7 Nov Dates - an apology and my final word on the issue [Stuart Healy ]
7 Nov GWR Western vs. Clark's Grebe [Terry Thomas ]
7 Nov Gilbert Water Ranch Sat 11-7-09 Clark's Grebe [Terry Thomas ]
7 Nov Park Hopping Tucson, AZ 11/6-11/7/09 [Robert Payne ]
7 Nov se AZ: Tucson Worm-eating Warbler at Desert Museum [Andrew Core ]
7 Nov Atascosa Highlands CBC January 3 [Rich Hoyer ]
7 Nov Re: NO SIGHTINGS: 2 cents on dating controversy [Frank Boyle ]
7 Nov NO SIGHTINGS: Comments on posting [vireo ]
6 Nov Re: NO SIGHTINGS: 2 (more) cents on dating controversy [Pat ]
6 Nov Tucson RBA delay [John Yerger ]
6 Nov Fossil Creek DIPPER, Nov. 4, 2005 [Grant And Tyler Loomis ]
6 Nov Re: NO SIGHTINGS: 2 cents on dating controversy [Bob Evans ]
6 Nov AZ: Whitewater Draw & Slaughter Ranch--06 Nov 09 [Erika Wilson ]
6 Nov SE AZ: Magnolia Warbler, Ft Lowell Pk, 11/6/09 [Richard Fray ]
6 Nov Re: NO SIGHTINGS: 1 cent on dating [Bill Butler ]
6 Nov Birds at Spirit Tree Inn Video-direct link [Rick and Ricki Thompson ]
6 Nov Composite Video-Five Birds at the Spirit Tree Inn-11/06/09 [Rick and Ricki Thompson ]
6 Nov SEAZ: Sweetwater Wetlands other goodies [Molly Pollock ]
6 Nov graham county birding november 5 [Phil Norton ]
6 Nov More on reporting []
6 Nov AZ:11/06/09:Magnolia Warbler Photos ["Clifford A. Cathers" ]
6 Nov The Miller House of Mesa - Male Magnificent Hummingbird - 11-6 [Jay Miller ]
6 Nov Re: NO SIGHTINGS: 2 cents on dating controversy [Jim Stuart ]
6 Nov AZ: Catalina State Park Varied Thrush [Rick Wright ]
6 Nov SEAZ Spirit Tree Inn Patagonia 11/6 [Spirit Tree Inn B & B ]
6 Nov Re: AZ:11/06/09:Fort Lowell Park Magnolia Warbler [John Yerger ]
6 Nov AZ: Tubac TENNESSEE WARBLER, AM. REDSTART [David Stejskal ]
6 Nov Re: AZ:11/06/09:Fort Lowell Park Magnolia Warbler [Mark Stevenson ]
6 Nov AZ: Boyce Thompson Arboretum 11/06/09 TWO Rufous-backed Robins [Richard Ditch ]
6 Nov SEAZ: Sweetwater - Golden-crowned Sparrow, Bona"parted"-Gulls, Tennesse Warbler [Molly Pollock ]
6 Nov AZ:11/06/09:Fort Lowell Park Magnolia Warbler ["Clifford A. Cathers" ]
6 Nov 2 cents on The Template--last? [D Wall ]
6 Nov SE AZ: 11/06/09 - SPRNCA Louisiana Waterthrush [Stuart Healy ]
6 Nov ABQ merlin - UNM area [Rob Yaksich ]
6 Nov mark your calendars Nov. 27, 2009 [Wezil Walraven ]
6 Nov Re: NO SIGHTINGS: 2 (more) cents on dating controversy [vivian mac kinnon ]
6 Nov Miller House of Mesa Possible Male Magnificent Hummer 11-6 [Jay Miller ]
6 Nov NO SIGHTINGS: 2 cents on dating controversy ["Myron L. Scott" ]
6 Nov Interesting woodpeckers - Santa Cruz near Tumacocori, AZ [Diane Touret ]
6 Nov AZFO - New photos: Rose-throated Becard, Rufous-backed Robin, Tennessee Warbler, Golden-crowned Sparrow, Chestnut-sided Warbler [Mike Moore ]
6 Nov NM: Dated Ladder-Backed Woodpecker Sandoval Co [Rick K ]
5 Nov AZ: Tucson Parks--05 Nov 09 [Erika Wilson ]
5 Nov Black-chinned Hummingbird in Tucson [Rich Hoyer ]
5 Nov Tucson parks 11.5 [Bev Postmus ]
5 Nov AZ: Kiwanis Park, Tempe, 4 Nov 2009 - Clark's Grebe continues [Bobby Metz ]
5 Nov AZ: Rufous-backed Robin at Boyce Thompson Arboretum near Superior, 11/5 [Susan Birky ]
5 Nov AZ: Madera Canyon - Black-capped Gnatcatcher & Yellow-bellied Sapsucker again [Laurens Halsey ]
5 Nov Glendale Recharge Ponds, 5 November 2009 [Tommy DeBardeleben ]
5 Nov SEAZ: Sweetwater Wetlands Golden-crowned Sparrow and others - 11/5/09 [Jake Mohlmann ]
5 Nov FW: Tucson Hooded Mergansers [Mark Stevenson ]
5 Nov SE AZ: Green Valley WWTP - 5 Nov 09 [Michael Marsden ]
5 Nov Patagonia AZ at Spirit Tree Inn Rufous-backed Robin [Spirit Tree Inn B & B ]
5 Nov Am. Crow near the San Pedro, Steller's Jay in Stump Canyon [Peter Sockness ]
5 Nov Re: Dateless in BIRDWG05 land, 5 November 2009 [Tommy DeBardeleben ]
5 Nov se AZ: Tucson Sweetwater Golden-crowned Sparrow [Andrew Core ]
5 Nov AZ, 5 Nov 09: Patagonia Gray Hawk, Western Tanager [Matt Brown ]
5 Nov Fw: eBird Report - Lakeside Park, Tucson [Mark Stevenson ]
5 Nov Re: Dateless - please skip unless particularly interested. [Gavin Bieber ]
5 Nov Se az: sweetwater possible golden-crowned sparrow [Andrew Core ]
5 Nov AZ: Tucson Peregrine [Rick Wright ]
5 Nov AZ: Arthur Pack Golf Course Pond [Philip Kline ]
5 Nov AZ: Sulphur Springs Valley White-tailed Kite, Nov. 4, 2009, 1145 [Glenn Klingler ]
5 Nov Yuma, AZ - 4 Nov 09, Golden-crowned Kinglet & Thick-billed Kingbird [Henry Detwiler ]
5 Nov Dateless in BIRDWG05 land [Stuart Healy ]
5 Nov NM RBA for 11/5/09 []
5 Nov Odd N. Flicker at Agua Caliente Park, Tucson [Diane Touret ]
5 Nov SE AZ: Patagonia Rufous-backed Robin, San Rafael Grasslands [Moez Ali ]
5 Nov Boyce Thompson Arboretum, AZ--Rufous-backed Robin still present [Gary Nunn ]

Subject: se AZ: Tucson - more Desert Museum notes
From: Andrew Core <andrewcore AT GMAIL.COM>
Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2009 14:38:13 -0700
Hi again,

In addition to the Worm-eating Warbler we also found a lowland
Golden-crowned Kinglet and a Black-chinned Sparrow, both in the Desert
Garden - classic "Patagonia Picnic Table Effect"!  The small courtyard with
the fountain was the last place I saw the Worm-eating Warbler (around
11:55am).  It was creating rustling noises at it searched through clusters
of dead leaves.

I don't suppose Black-chinned Sparrow is too awful rare here, but it was
nice to see.  Pretty cool to see a Golden-crowned Kinglet down in the
lowlands, and even cooler to see one perched in cholla and creosote!  The
one we saw was evidently a female, but I could have sworn I heard more than
one.  Tough to tell, given the ventriloquistic nature of their calls.  Did
you know they have yellow feet?

Also around were Northern Cardinal, Hutton's Vireo, a Empidonax sp.
flycatcher, Hermit Thrushes, and Mark told me about a Townsend's Warbler in
the Riparian Area.

I checked the CAP basin on Mile Wide Rd on the way home and didn't see a
single duck, just coots and 3 Double-crested Cormorants.

good birding-
Andrew


On Sat, Nov 7, 2009 at 1:38 PM, John Yerger wrote:

> 11/07/2009: Arizona Sonoran-Desert Museum (path to the Desert Garden)
>
>
-- 

Andrew Core
Tucson, AZ
Subject: test
From: Carolyn Pitts <cpitts AT ZETACORP.COM>
Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2009 14:01:34 -0700
Carolyn Pitts
Subject: AZ: Worm-eating Warbler photos
From: John Yerger <john AT ADVENTUREBIRDING.COM>
Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2009 13:38:36 -0700
11/07/2009: Arizona Sonoran-Desert Museum (path to the Desert Garden)

Mark Stevenson and Molly Pollock were the first to spot the bird this 
morning at 8:30AM; the rest of us had to wait some time before the bird 
returned again for good views.  Andrew Core probably secured some better 
photographs, but for those immediately interested in documentation 
quality images:


http://adventurebirding.blogspot.com/2009/11/worm-eating-warbler-arizona-sonoran.html 


Thanks again to Susan Parker-Hotchkiss, museum docent, who apparently 
found this bird on 11/05/2009!  Also thanks to Andrew and his internet 
phone technology for immediately getting the word out on this bird.

Cheers,
John Yerger
Tucson, AZ
----------
Adventure Birding Company
www.adventurebirding.com
Subject: seaz-Spirit Tree Inn Patagonia Az
From: Spirit Tree Inn B & B <Spiritreeinn AT AOL.COM>
Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2009 14:44:03 EST
Matt Brown saw the rufous-backed robin at 7:00 & 7:45 am at Spirit Tree  
Inn on 11/7/09
Jerome Smith saw 2 different rufous-backed robins, a Townsend solitaire and 
 10 waxwings at 11:00 am on 11/7/09.  Thank you to all who called or 
emailed  us before coming to visit.  We appreciate it very much.
 
 
Mary Jane,  Tom & Joe
Spirit Tree Inn B & B
3 Harshaw Creek Road
Patagonia  Arizona 85624
1-520-394-0121
1-866-394-0121 Toll free
1-520-401-0541  Verizon cell #
www.spirittreeinn.com
Subject: Re: Dates - an apology and my final word on the issue
From: Richard Ditch <richditch AT EARTHLINK.NET>
Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2009 12:28:29 -0700
There is never a guarantee that a post will appear on the date  
submitted, and I know I've seen posts stating ,,, today ... " that  
clearly refer to a date prior to the listserv/email time stamp.

For the simple goal of being unambiguous and making a posted report  
as useful as it can be it seems prudent to include the date  
prominently in the subject line and/or the body of the message. Just  
like spelling out the name of a species rather than using 4 letter  
codes is an easy way to make a post most useful and least ambiguous  
for other readers.

Rich Ditch
Phoenix, AZ

web site: www.richditch.com
photo blog: richditch.wordpress.com



On Nov 7, 2009, at 12:19 PM, Edward Boyd wrote:

> Stuart,
>
> My thoughts on this has always been that the date and time stamp of  
> the post was indicative of the sighting date. If I was posting  
> information about a sighting prior to the date I was posting it,  
> then this would be included for the reader's benefit. Otherwise, I  
> assume that all post are current for the day of posting. That just  
> seemed logical for me. Even a search of the list serve records  
> displays the date and time of the posting, so to me that's a given.
>
> Stuart Healy wrote:
>> I find it puzzling that those very same birders seem unwilling to  
>> take a few extra seconds to include a date that unambiguously
>> defines the sighting date. Is this an unreasonable expectation?
>>
Subject: Re: Dates - an apology and my final word on the issue
From: Edward Boyd <edboyd1959 AT COMCAST.NET>
Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2009 14:19:45 -0500
Stuart,

My thoughts on this has always been that the date and time stamp of the 
post was indicative of the sighting date. If I was posting information 
about a sighting prior to the date I was posting it, then this would be 
included for the reader's benefit. Otherwise, I assume that all post are 
current for the day of posting. That just seemed logical for me. Even a 
search of the list serve records displays the date and time of the 
posting, so to me that's a given.

Stuart Healy wrote:
> I find it puzzling that those very same birders 
> seem unwilling to take a few extra seconds to include a date that 
unambiguously 

> defines the sighting date. Is this an unreasonable expectation? 
>
>   
Subject: FWD: Flagstaff White-throated Sparrow
From: Moez Ali <moezali15 AT GMAIL.COM>
Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2009 11:36:31 -0700
Atlanta birder friend Stephen Barlow reports the following:

A couple of late reports:
 Yesterday morning (Nov 6) I saw an adult "tan-striped" WHITE-THROATED
SPARROW at the large parking lot with restrooms and a boat ramp at
Upper Lake Mary nr Flagstaff. The bird  was foraging with a mixed
Oregon / Pink-sided / Gray-headed / Red-backed Junco flock in the
weeds between the parking lot and the lake "beach". A couple of
Townsend's Solitaires were present here, with another couple at the
Mormon Lake overlook. Just past the Mormon Lake overlook I was
surprised to see a Roadrunner run across the road. Both Mormon Lake
and Lower Lake Mary were dry, but there were a large number of
waterfowl on Upper Lake Mary.

On the morning of Nov 5, I was at Sweetwater Wetlands in Tucson. Not
sure  whether others have reported these recently, but I thought a
White-breasted Nuthatch (NE corner near "hidden pond" and Cassin's
Vireo (as well as Plumbeous)  were at least moderately noteworthy.
Thanks to whom I believe from other posts must have been Jake Mohlmann
for telling me exactly where the Tennesee Warbler was hanging out. I
had great views from outside the fence just E of the turning circle at
the E of Roger Rd.

Cheers
Steve

Stephen Barlow,
Principal Research Scientist,
School of Chemistry and Biochemistry,
Georgia Institute of Technology,
Atlanta GA 30332-0400, USA
phone: 404-385-6053
fax: 404-894-5909
email: stephen.barlow AT chemistry.gatech.edu
Subject: AZ: Ft. Lowell Park MAGNOLIA WARBLER continues
From: David Stejskal <dstejskal AT COX.NET>
Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2009 13:23:54 -0500
Hi birders,

Just got back from nearby Ft. Lowell Park on Craycroft and Glenn in Tucson. The 
MAGNOLIA WARBLER found yesterday was still present as of this morning (11/7) in 
the row of Cottonwood trees on the west side of the park. A nice, confiding 
pair of GREAT HORNED OWLS was also present in this line of trees and about a 
dozen WESTERN BLUEBIRDS and a dozen or more CEDAR WAXWINGS were also just to 
the north of the Cottonwoods. No sign of the Wood Duck or the Lewis's 
Woodpecker. 


Cheers,

Dave Stejskal
Field Guides Inc.
www.fieldguides.com
800-728-4953
Subject: Dates - an apology and my final word on the issue
From: Stuart Healy <stuarthealy AT COX.NET>
Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2009 11:11:50 -0700
I want to apologize for my recent ill-advised, over-the-top and personalized
"dateless" post. Put it down to being passionate about what I do coupled
with a lack of social skills, obviously a dangerous combination.

My final (hopefully, more moderate) words on this issue follow. 

After spending time in the field, many birders take the time to put together a 
post 

of their sightings for the benefit of others. I find it puzzling that those 
very same birders 

seem unwilling to take a few extra seconds to include a date that unambiguously
defines the sighting date. Is this an unreasonable expectation? 

Stuart

Stuart Healy, Western U.S. Bird Guide,
Specializing in SE Arizona and the White Mountains.
Personal Guiding and Custom Tours; 
220 Stardust St., Sierra Vista, AZ 85635.
(520) 458-7603 mailto:stuarthealy AT cox.net
http://www.aztrogon.com
Birding journal: http://www.aztrogon.com/journal/Main.htm
Subject: GWR Western vs. Clark's Grebe
From: Terry Thomas <tntx2 AT COX.NET>
Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2009 10:07:50 -0700
I posted that this was a Clark's after viewing but each time I look at it I 
change my mind. I will send photos tot he experts fro confirmation but would 
appreciate any input from the birders at GWR this am. The bird was very mottled 
like the Clark's and the face was more like the Clark's but the bill looks like 
a Western's in color. 


Terry
Subject: Gilbert Water Ranch Sat 11-7-09 Clark's Grebe
From: Terry Thomas <tntx2 AT COX.NET>
Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2009 09:59:56 -0700
We spent a few hours birding this morning at GWR. Besides the usuals we were 
surprised to see the Avocet on pond 5 was still with us minus a leg. The right 
leg was pretty damaged and has now fallen off. Despite this, the bird seems to 
be able to forage well and is surviving. 


We saw 2 juvenile Turkey vultures. Some thought at first they might be Black 
Vultures but we reviewed our pictures and they look like juveniles. They landed 
on the communication pole by the central ranger/bathrooms and gave us some nice 
pictures. They flew off and later we saw them on one of the telephone poles 
across Guadalupe. The highlight of the day was a Clark's Grebe on pond 7. He 
was giving us nice views. We are still novices at birding but we studies this 
bird pretty well and believe it is a Clark's. Is this unusual as I never recall 
anyone posting one for GWR. It was hanging with a Pied-Billed. 


Other notables included an Osprey hunting over pond 7 and a nice show of a 
Great Blue eating a large fish. 


Terry and Terry
Subject: Park Hopping Tucson, AZ 11/6-11/7/09
From: Robert Payne <vermillion233 AT HOTMAIL.COM>
Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2009 09:42:28 -0700
Did a lot of park hopping these last two days. 
11/6/09
Started at Sweetwater Wetlands did not see much in the hour and half I was 
there. Heard the vireo, but no luck with the sparrow or the Tennessee Warbler. 

At about 8:30 I arrived at McCormick Park where I ran into Jake Mohlmann and 
Lucy. They found the RED-BREASTED SAPSUCKER for me in the large Pistachio? Tree 
at the far south east corner of the park. 

Other good stuff where the two continuing Meadowlarks, 2 Northern (Red-Shafted) 
Flicker, and the male Red-Naped Sapsucker. After that Reid Park was very slow 
with grounds keepers working in the 

grassy knolls. I was able to locate the Acorn Woodpecker in the tallest of the 
Eucalyptus trees near the baseball field. I also saw a juvie Red-Tailed Hawk 
sitting about a foot from a adult Cooper's Hawk without 

any dispute, it was quite odd. 

Near dusk I tried for the Magnolia Warbler at Ft. Lowell Park. I ran into Jerry 
Bock and Andrew Core who had seen it before I arrived. I had a fleeting glimpse 
in my hour and half there, not very satisfactory. There where also Western 
Bluebirds, A female Dark-Eyed (Oregon) Junco, a very pretty Great-Horned Owl 
beeing mobbed by a group of four Anna's Hummers, and a single Male Cassin's 
Finch perched up nicely in the tree above the Cottonwood Lane Restrooms for a 
few minuetes before flying north and out of the park. 


11/7/09
Had a jump start with my grandmother Joyce Lebowitz, on the MAGNOLIA WARBLER 
this morning. The bird was seen well between 7:45 and 8:00 by a group of five 
birders. It was still foraging with the group of Ruby-Crowned Kinglets acting a 
lot like a Redstart. It even gave us some almost eye-level out in the open 
views for seconds at a time. No Cassin's Finch this morning but a flock of 
Cedar Waxwings can be added to list with the Bluebird flock. Went back to 
McCormick Park to try find the RED-BREASTED SAPSUCKER for my grandma. We where 
succsessful within minuets of walking to the previously mentioned tree. It 
stayed in the tree for only about two minuetes before flying to the west along 
the southern edge of the park into a identical looking tree. I re-found it in 
the tree and got some video footage of it associating with local Red-Naped 
Sapsucker. For at least five minutes the two of them foraged inches from 
eachother on the same branch, it was quite a sight. 


I will upload the pics and video on Monday when next have the oppurtunity. 

Good Birding, 
Rob Payne
 		 	   		  
_________________________________________________________________
Bing brings you maps, menus, and reviews organized in one place.

http://www.bing.com/search?q=restaurants&form=MFESRP&publ=WLHMTAG&crea=TEXT_MFESRP_Local_MapsMenu_Resturants_1x1 
Subject: se AZ: Tucson Worm-eating Warbler at Desert Museum
From: Andrew Core <andrewcore AT GMAIL.COM>
Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2009 09:27:37 -0700
Howdy birders,

I just got a text from John Yerger that a WORM-EATING WARBLER was seen
at 8:30am in the Desert Garden at the Arizona-Sonora Desert Museum
west of Tucson (directions in either bird-finding guide, or google
it).

It has perhaps been there since yesterday, seen initially by Susan
Hotchkiss.  John has obtained some "OK photos".

More details as they develop from people who know more about it than I do...
Andrew

--
Andrew Core
Tucson, AZ
Subject: Atascosa Highlands CBC January 3
From: Rich Hoyer <birdernaturalist AT ME.COM>
Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2009 08:34:02 -0700
Hi All,

Jake Mohlmann and I are the compilers for the Atascosa Highlands  
Christmas Bird Count, and we're in the major recruiting phase now. By  
mid-December we will be getting all the information packets together  
and sent out to team leaders. If you are interested in participating  
in this most spectacular of counts, please get in touch with either of  
us when you know your schedule. A list of all the Arizona CBCs can be  
found here: http://www.tucsonaudubon.org/what-we-do/birding/198.html.

This circle is centered NW of Nogales and includes all of the Atascosa  
and Pajarito Mountains, Sycamore Canyon, California Gulch, Arivaca  
Lake, and Peńa Blanca Lake. It's mostly wild, roadless area with  
barely 1/2 mile of pavement in the circle. We don't have any Rock  
Doves, rarely European Starlings or House Sparrows, and are the only  
CBC in the country to have Five-striped Sparrow on its list (though it  
is a rarity in winter). Volunteers do need to have a certain level of  
physical ability and be willing to walk or hike on rough, uneven  
surfaces, and those with high clearance vehicles and ability to hike  
cross country are especially in need.

Last year we had several all-time national highs. Below my signature I  
will paste in the summary that posted to this earlier this year.

We do have a countdown compilation dinner, which is half the fun of  
the day's birding – where you get to share your sightings and hear  
what other birders found during the day. I look forward to hearing  
from many of you.

Good Birding,

Rich
---
Rich Hoyer
Tucson, Arizona
http://birdernaturalist.blogspot.com/

Senior Leader for WINGS
http://wingsbirds.com
---
Dear Birders,

With the exciting Christmas Bird Count season coming to a close, we
compilers are still busy completing our number crunching and
submitting the final data to the National Audubon Society. I have the
final results from the Atascosa Highlands CBC, which Jake Mohlmann and
I revived this season after a 6-year hiatus. The count was held on
Monday, December 15, 2008.

The circle includes the famous birding areas of Sycamore Canyon and
California Gulch, and by a mere 1/2 mile or less also includes Peńa
Blanca Lake in the SE and Arivaca Lake in the NW. The count enjoyed
the hard work of 55 participants who were divided up into 21 teams.
This is well above the average number of participants for this remote
area with only about 5 residences actually within the circle
(including those hermit miners way out in California Gulch), and
almost all participants had to drive more than an hour from home to
get to their area. We even had participants come from as far as
Portal, Flagstaff and Paso Robles, California.

The total number of species tallied was 139, which beats the old
record of 136, set in 1991 (the year that this was the "featured
count" and received special statewide attention). The total number of
individual birds was 6850, well below average.

An amazing 8 species and one form were new to the all time list
(spanning 25 years, from 1977-2001):
Greater Scaup (Papago Tanks)
Hooded Merganser (Arivaca Lake)
Brown Pelican (Arivaca Lake)
Whiskered Screech-Owl (Sycamore and Peck Canyons; surprisingly not
seen or heard on previous counts, as it is common in the circle)
Short-eared Owl (Corral Nuevo Road)
Red-breasted Sapsucker (Sycamore Canyon)
"Brown-throated" House Wren (Pine Canyon)
Olive Warbler (Pine Canyon)
Western Tanager (Sycamore Canyon)

Species seen for only the second time since 1977 were:
Barn Owl (1 in Oro Blanco Wash)
Common Poorwill (1 on  Ruby Road at mile post 1 west of Peńa Blanca
Lake)
Eastern Phoebe (1 in Oro Blanco Wash). Interestingly, 3 others were
seen in the count circle in the prior weeks.
Black-capped Gnatcatcher (3; two at Arivaca Lake and 1 in California
Gulch)

Species seen for only the third time since 1977 were:
Crested Caracara (lower California Gulch)
Western Scrub-Jay (Rock Corral, Corral Nuevo, Atascosa Lookout)
Abert's Towhee (Arivaca Lake, Bellota Canyon, Peńa Blanca Lake)

We matched or set new high counts for 35 species, but for some the
number was notably high. Five of them were new all-time national
highs. These were:
Montezuma Quail (268)
Elegant Trogon (4)
Painted Redstart (14)
Hepatic Tanager (27)
Scott's Oriole (29)

Falling just short of all-time national highs were Gray Flycatcher
(59) and Black-throated Gray Warbler (31). Very high for Arizona were
totals of Cassin's Kingbird (19), Hutton's Vireo (81), and Townsend's
Warbler (16), all of which have much larger wintering populations in
California.

This circle also holds all-time national highs for five additional
species:
Mexican Jay (1110 in 1991), Bridled Titmouse (574 in 1991), Rock Wren
(300 in 1979), Canyon Wren (213 in 1991), and Rufous-crowned Sparrow
(460 in 1991). Our count for Mexican Jay this year (321) was below
average, and for Bridled Titmouse (216) was slightly above average.
The Portal and Patagonia CBC circles sometimes have numbers rivaling
these, but these could still be the national high this year. The
remaining three have their stronghold in this circle and these should
be national highs this year hands down: Rock Wren (147, 8th highest),
Canyon Wren (125, 2nd highest), and Rufous-crowned Sparrow (244, 3rd
highest).

The tentative date for next year's Atascosa Highlands CBC is SUNDAY,
JANUARY 3, 2010. Mark your calendars, come join the fun, and help set
some new records.

Good Birding,

Rich
---

---
Rich Hoyer
Tucson, Arizona
http://birdernaturalist.blogspot.com/

Senior Leader for WINGS
http://wingsbirds.com
---
Subject: Re: NO SIGHTINGS: 2 cents on dating controversy
From: Frank Boyle <ravenfrank AT EARTHLINK.NET>
Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2009 14:48:23 +0000
Hmmm... Even though I live in MD I can relate to e-mail list controversies. 
Just the mere mention of, say, cats and birds sets our bird forum (MDOSPREY) 
aflame. Good to see that birders everywhere are a cantankerous bunch! I usually 
just try to laugh it off, shut down the computer, and go birding. 


Frank Boyle
Rohrersville, MD (and sometimes Tucson)
Ravenfrank AT earthlink.net
Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry
Subject: NO SIGHTINGS: Comments on posting
From: vireo <vireo AT VIREOS.COM>
Date: Sat, 7 Nov 2009 06:09:06 -0700
Birders,

 

Please note:  These are my opinions.  They may be freely ignored.

 

I would like to make a couple of comments on posting to the listserv.  There
has been quite a bit of discussion about including dates and other
information in posts.  When this discussion becomes mean-spirited, as it has
on occasion, it is not appropriate for this listserv.  This is true whether
it is part of this discussion or in other circumstances.

 

There are lots of people on this listserv (over 1000).  Most of them do not
post anything.  I want to remind you that just posting to the listserv does
not make someone an expert on birds or make their opinion count more than
someone else's opinion.  We have everyone from beginners to experts on this
forum, and you cannot tell them apart by the quantity of their posts, or
even the nature of their signature line.  This listserv should be a place to
learn about birds and birding as well as a place to share information about
where to find rare birds.

 

This is an excellent listserv.  There is far less flaming than on other
listservs I have been (and still are) on.  Let's keep it that way by being
polite and non-judgmental in our posts.

 

Remember these are just my opinions.  If you take them and $3 and you can
get a cup of black Starbuck's coffee.

 

Now let's go birding/

 

Dave

 

David Powell

Phoenix, AZ

vireo AT vireos.com

 
Subject: Re: NO SIGHTINGS: 2 (more) cents on dating controversy
From: Pat <pgoltz AT SEGHEA.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 23:14:44 -0700
Another 1c:

It's too dark outside to bird right now, so here I am.

I find it somewhat intimidating that some people come across as knowing
so much more than I and making me feel like I'm out of place. Maybe
unintentional, but encouraging relative newcomers to birding should
certainly be on the agenda. Most people don't do this, but a few
sometimes do.

I'd never remember posting rules anyway. Who has time to go hunt up the
long explanations every time she wants to say something?

Pat Goltz

vivian mac kinnon wrote:
> Howdy Birdsters,
> 
> OK, I usually to stay out of these things as I'd rather be birding...
> 
> 
> BUT, bottom line is I don't want this sort of
> thing/discussion/rants/finger-pointing to STOP people from posting.
> We all learn who-to-read, who-not-to-read, and have different
> opinions on how to post, etc.
> 
> Using my prerogative, I comply with reasonable requests, especially
> if it is somebody trying to use my info for some/any sort of data
> collecting, as I hate collecting/entering/compiling data - god-dog
> bless them for it, especially when they share!
> 
> My request is simple, please don't let any of this stuff stop you
> from posting your sightings! I recently met a gal that thought she
> saw a Philly Vireo at Ft. Lowell Park but was afraid to post it to
> us...we're too scary and there's so much "e-blood" flowing...crap!
> Now the bird is gone and we'll never know...
> 
> Make your own rules but please, please, please, keep posting...um,
> bird sightings that is.
> 
> Going birding now, hope you will too! Virtual Vivian
> 
Subject: Tucson RBA delay
From: John Yerger <john AT ADVENTUREBIRDING.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 23:08:52 -0700
This week's edition of the Tucson RBA will be delayed until 11/07/2009 
(rather than 11/06).  Thank you for your patience!

Cheers,
John Yerger
RBA Compiler
Tucson, AZ


(And if you're impatient, please bear in mind this is a volunteer effort!)
Subject: Fossil Creek DIPPER, Nov. 4, 2005
From: Grant And Tyler Loomis <moalty21 AT COX.NET>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 22:19:49 -0700
I apologize for the late post. On Wednesday Nov. 4 I spotted an American 
Dipper on Fossil Creek at the popular waterfall site about one mile 
upstream from Irving. The bird was making forays through the large pool at 
the base of the waterfall. The only other notable bird on the trail to the 
waterfall was a Townsends Solitaire.
Grant Loomis
Subject: Re: NO SIGHTINGS: 2 cents on dating controversy
From: Bob Evans <REvans9173 AT AOL.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 22:16:47 EST
If all of the pertinent information is included in the post, what  
difference does it make how is organized?
 
Bob Evans
Cascabel, AZ
 
 
Subject: AZ: Whitewater Draw & Slaughter Ranch--06 Nov 09
From: Erika Wilson <terika88 AT COX.NET>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 19:56:57 -0700
Hi, birders,

Whitewater Draw--06 Nov 09

Birds of interest at Whitewater Draw this morning were: Snow Goose (4),
Canada Goose (4), Western Grebe (2), Black-crowned Night-Heron (1 imm), but
no Am. Bittern, alas. We heard a single Virgina Rail and a single Sora
calling from the reeds, but neither came out. Shorebirds highlights were
Long-billed Curlew (8), Least Sandpiper (38), and a Wilson's Snipe.

Best raptor was a female Merlin, while the only owl was a Great Horned Owl
in the barn rafters. Four Violet-green Swallows were the only swallows.

Slaughter Ranch--06 Nov 09

After lunch we spent an hour at Slaughter Ranch, where a male Redhead in
eclipse plumage was an interesting find. Other ducks were Gadwall, Am.
Wigeon, and Ring-necked Ducks. A Great Egret was working the edge of the
pond, and a Merlin made several passes over the pond. In the cottonwoods
around the pond the most interesting birds were a male Red-naped Sapsucker
and a Belted Kingfisher, while in the grasses we had Am. Pipit (7), Chipping
Sparrow (2), and a surprising Grasshopper Sparrow. This latter was behaving
like a mouse, scurrying along through the rank grasses.

The day's tally was 66 species. A final note was a Bobcat crossing Geronimo
Trail at the paved/unpaved interface coming into Douglas.

Cheers, Erika Wilson (Sierra Vista, AZ)

Subject: SE AZ: Magnolia Warbler, Ft Lowell Pk, 11/6/09
From: Richard Fray <rpfray AT DAKOTACOM.NET>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 18:08:35 -0700
As reported, the MAGNOLIA WARBLER continued until at least 4pm in Fort Lowell 
Park in Tucson. It took me a while to find and was quite difficult to follow 
once I had, energetically feeding in the canopy. It spent most of its time in 
the third tree on the right as you walk along the avenue of cottonwoods from 
the parking lot. 


I too managed a few record shots: 
http://www.rpf-wildlife-photos.com/blog/?p=852. They're no better than anybody 
else's... 


A smart PEREGRINE passed overhead at 3:30pm, and a flock of about ten WESTERN 
BLUEBIRDS put on a decent show. A few CEDAR WAXWINGS were also in the area, as 
was a RED-NAPED SAPSUCKER. 


Richard Fray
Tucson AZ




-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 

      Richard Fray, NorthStewart
      Web Design & Hosting
      3531 E Florence Dr
      Tucson AZ 85716   |
      |
      |
      | Office: (520) 323-4234
      Cell: (520) 490-9287
      www.northstewart.com
      richard AT northstewart.com 
Subject: Re: NO SIGHTINGS: 1 cent on dating
From: Bill Butler <thewdata_sa AT YAHOO.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 18:06:38 -0700
I have enjoyed many of the posts, dated sightings or otherwise.  Lets see if
I can say this without further ruffling any feathers, but one of the
functions of the postings is to provide information and so a few details on
date, time, location and directions are much appreciated and frequently
useful to folks like myself.

Cheers,
Bill
Subject: Birds at Spirit Tree Inn Video-direct link
From: Rick and Ricki Thompson <rixandzax AT AOL.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 17:23:25 -0700
I hope this direct link works.  One of the clips is of the Rufous-backed 
Robin:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BwIchiE2IFw

Rick Thompson
Subject: Composite Video-Five Birds at the Spirit Tree Inn-11/06/09
From: Rick and Ricki Thompson <rixandzax AT AOL.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 17:08:33 -0700
This two-minute video containing clips collected between 0800 and 1400 
today (11/06/09)includes the following birds:

Red-naped Sapsucker-showing its chickadee-like feeding behavior in the 
pyracantha tree/bush on the patio/courtyard.

Townsend's Solitaire-perched in pyracantha.

Fox Sparrow (slate-colored)-two clips, first in a bush, then in the 
pyracantha.

Black-chinned Sparrow-perched in tree.

Rufous-backed Robin-two clips, first in pyracantha, second perched in 
mesquite (I wish the camera had been more stable for the second one 
because the view was great!)

These sightings were reported earlier today by the hosts of the Inn 
located near Patagonia.  Our thanks to them.  Their enthusiasm is 
contagious.

For some reason, the YouTube URL doesn't copy to provide a direct link.  
To view this video:

www.youtube.com
type "rixandzax" into the search window
click on the thumbnail

Rick and Ricki Thompson
Sierra Vista AZ
Subject: SEAZ: Sweetwater Wetlands other goodies
From: Molly Pollock <mollymp AT FLASH.NET>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 17:02:27 -0700
Hello Birders,

Some other goodies I observed today at Sweetwater Wetlands included (in no 
special order): Cassin's Kingbird, Spotted Towhee, Bewick's Wren, Yellow 
Warbler, Prairie and Peregrine Falcon's, Red-naped Sapsucker, and Dark-eyed 
Junco. My total today was 89 species, short of Jerry's 100 goal. However, 
others told me of species I missed, such of White-breasted Nuthatch, Plumbeous 
Vireo, and Rick T. and Barbara B. had an American Robin and Wood Duck across 
the street at Roger Rd. WRF. This was the first day this fall that I did NOT 
see a swallow at Sweetwater. 


Good Birding,

Molly Pollock
Tucson, AZ
Subject: graham county birding november 5
From: Phil Norton <philnorton AT COX.NET>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 18:51:14 -0500
From route 191 south of Safford, the road leads up through the Pinaleno 
Mountains to high elevations, reaching Riggs Flat Lake after 34 miles, the last 
12 being unpaved. Birding along the road was mostly slow. One mile before the 
turn in to the Lake, 3 wild turkeys crossed the road. At the Lake was an adult 
bald eagle. There were many red-breasted nuthatches, more than I have seen on 
this route before. I was a bit surprised to find yellow-rumped warblers still 
present at several different spots--will they try to stay through the winter? 
At Snow Flat (mile 135) there were 8 golden-crowned kinglets. There were some 
American robins and hermit thrushes around, and western bluebirds were 
widespread and abundant, but I saw only one Townsend's solitaire.There were 3 
Cassin's finches, one male and two females, perched high on the bare branches 
of a spruce at mile 130. But no red crossbills (I did not happen to be where 
they were) and no pine siskins (more surprising). 


At Roper Lake there were 7 western grebes, a great egret, 2 common moorhens, 
and 9 species of ordinary waterfowl, including 4 lesser scaup. Also an osprey. 


The Reay Road sewage treatment plant at Thatcher (west of Safford on US 70) 
currently suffers from very low water levels: the north basins which in earlier 
years have been full, are now dry, and the water level in the marsh also is 
low. But it still is worth checking. Two Virginia rails, as well as several 
soras, called from the marsh. On the ponds were a few more ducks, including 4 
scaup (all lesser, I fear) and one blue-winged teal. The shorebirds consisted 
of exactly one spotted sandpiper! What was new here was a burrowing owl. Locate 
it thus: go to the northwest corner of the westernmost pond, then cross the 
roadway to the north, and look along the drainage ditch. It seems to like the 
culvert there. 


I arrived at Cluff Ranch (an Az Game and Fish area south of Pima) at 4:45, with 
the sun already dipping behind the mountains. Noteworthy were 10 cedar 
waxwings, in a large dead cottonwood, with four red-naped sapsuckers. 

                                                                Phil Norton
                                                               Mesa, Az
Subject: More on reporting
From: Pinyonjay AT AOL.COM
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 18:38:24 EST
As a person who does the NM RBA, some things are helpful from  reporters.  
Putting AZ or NM in the line helps me decide which to look at,  it takes 
time to read reports to see the source.  Putting the dates helps  with rarer 
birds for those who want to try to see the bird, and when it was last  
reported. I need first and last names, which are often left out. And of course 
I 

need the bird's names!  In the line helps, but I read all NM  reports.  I 
have no objection to persons reporting what is interesting to  them.  
Directions help us chasers know how to get to where the rarities are to be 
found. 

I include not only extreme rarities but things about migrants  and 
sightings.  A lot depends on the length of my usual long reports.
 
Pat Snider
NM RBA
 
 
Subject: AZ:11/06/09:Magnolia Warbler Photos
From: "Clifford A. Cathers" <AZCLIFFY AT Q.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 16:31:46 -0700
I went back to Fort Lowell Park and snapped a few photos of the previously 
reported MAGNOLIA WARBLER.  John Yerger may have done better, I'm not sure 
(!).  My photos at least add to the record with a few good field marks.

This morning, the sun was out and bright and the warbler was low in the 
cottonwoods further along the lane.  When I returned this afternoon, John, 
Morgan, Mark and Molly (and others) were already on the bird in the third 
cottonwood on the right as you face Craycroft Road.

However, this afternoon, the bird was flitting high in the cottonwood, 
often concealed, and photography was challenging at best.  Add to that, the 
sudden cloud cover due to the low pressure rolling under Arizona and I 
think we were lucky to get photos at all!

Here's the link to my website:

http://www.economybirding.com/Rarities02.html

If you click on each photo individually, you'll get a larger view in a 
separate window.

The first photo caught a hard to see field mark, the gray band across the 
throat separating the yellow throat and yellow breast.  You can also see 
the faint black streaks along the side of the breast, the gray cheeks and 
whitish eyering.  The second photo, though blurry, shows the black tail 
tips, the eyering, the grayish head and one hint of a white wingbar.  The 
last photo, though covered by leaves, shows the white undertail coverts and 
tail, the yellow breast with faint black side streaks, the head and eyering 
and a decent view of the gray band across the upper chest again.  

I hope the bird sticks around for some better photos...

Clifford A. Cathers
Economy Birding Services, Inc.
"Quality Birding With Your Budget in Mind"
http://www.economybirding.com
Budget Bird Guiding for the Desert Southwest
AZCliffy AT q.com
Subject: The Miller House of Mesa - Male Magnificent Hummingbird - 11-6
From: Jay Miller <arizonajay23 AT COX.NET>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 15:09:39 -0800
Indeed it is a Male MAHU. I went out back at about 10:00 and could hear it 
chipping quite loud. It was so loud I thought at first it was some type of 
sparrow or warbler. I found it perched at the end of a pine branch. It then 
flew to my front trees and then over them and south. Then at 11:03 it was at my 
office feeder. It's huge! Hopefully it will stick around awhile. Yard bird #142 


Jay Miller
Mesa, AZ
Subject: Re: NO SIGHTINGS: 2 cents on dating controversy
From: Jim Stuart <jnstuart61 AT YAHOO.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 15:10:51 -0800
Putting the state, location, and possibly species in the Subject line (e.g., 
"NM: Albuq.: Peregrine") is a nice courtesy for those who get bombarded by 
emails and are trying to sort out the useful ones from the not so useful. There 
is a lot of volume on this listserv and I suspect few have the time to read 
everything. It's not impatience, it's how you use your time. 


Attaching a date to an observation seems pretty basic if you want it to be 
biologically useful in understanding bird migration, breeding, etc. Or to be 
useful to other birders, such as those on this listserv. 

 

Thanks,
Jim

James N. Stuart 
Albuquerque, NM 
jnstuart61 AT yahoo.com
http://flickr.com/photos/stuartwildlife





________________________________
From: Myron L. Scott 
To: BIRDWG05 AT LISTSERV.ARIZONA.EDU
Sent: Fri, November 6, 2009 8:55:05 AM
Subject: [BIRDWG05] NO SIGHTINGS: 2 cents on dating controversy

Seems to me:

    Every few months there's a new spasm of demands for all posters to adopt a 
specific posting format: 




Subject: AZ: Catalina State Park Varied Thrush
From: Rick Wright <birdaz AT GMAIL.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 15:34:45 -0700
This morning's highlight at Catalina State Park was a male Varied Thrush
that flew through the signposted Picnic Area shortly before 8:00 am. The
bird kept going--I suppose any site in Oro Valley with water and fruit might
have been his destination.

-- 
Rick Wright

Managing Director, WINGS
http://wingsbirds.com
http://birdaz.com, http://birdaz.com/blog
Subject: SEAZ Spirit Tree Inn Patagonia 11/6
From: Spirit Tree Inn B & B <Spiritreeinn AT AOL.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 17:23:58 EST
Rick and Ricki Thompson from Sierra Vista saw a red napped sapsucker, a  
Townsends's Solitaire and a Rufous-backed Robin between 8:30 and 10:00 am in 
the  patio of the Spirit Tree Inn B & B outside Patagonia Arizona.  From  
10:30 am - 12:45 pm Mark and Farrish Sharon saw a Slate Fox sparrow, a  
Black-chinned sparrow and a Rufous-backed robin at the same site. If you would 

like to come to our patio, we would appreciate your calling call us and  let 
us know how many are in your party and when you will be coming.  We are  a 
bed and breakfast and preparing for our guests is our first priority.   Thank 
you.
 
 
Mary Jane,  Tom & Joe
Spirit Tree Inn B & B
3 Harshaw Creek Rd
Patagonia  Arizona 85624
866-394-0121 toll free #
520-401-0541 Verizon cell #
_www.spirittreeinn.com_ (http://www.spirittreeinn.com/)  web  site
spiritreeinn AT aol.com email
Subject: Re: AZ:11/06/09:Fort Lowell Park Magnolia Warbler
From: John Yerger <john AT ADVENTUREBIRDING.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 15:11:20 -0700
After successfully relocating the MAGNOLIA WARBLER, I got home and 
checked out my pictures...not the best, but hopefully enough to document 
the sighting:


http://adventurebirding.blogspot.com/2009/11/magnolia-warbler-fort-lowell-park.html 



Shortly after we arrived at the park, Cliff returned with camera in 
hand.  Hopefully he got some photos with better clarity!

Good birding,
John Yerger
Tucson, AZ
----------
Adventure Birding Company
www.adventurebirding.com
Subject: AZ: Tubac TENNESSEE WARBLER, AM. REDSTART
From: David Stejskal <dstejskal AT COX.NET>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 14:00:46 -0800
Hi birders,

I had a delightful time birding the Santa Cruz R. south of the Tubac bridge for 
a few hours this morning. One of the first birds I had was a very bright 
TENNESSEE WARBLER at the bridge on the north side and just on the west edge of 
the stream. It was foraging very deliberately in the first small willow shrubs 
that you get to on the north side of the bridge on the west bank of the river 
as you walk to the east from the Bridge Rd./Calle Iglesia intersection. I first 
found it around 8:15 this morning, and subsequently lost it, but it was back in 
the same willow when I returned to the bridge at about 11:30. The AMERICAN 
REDSTART, a gorgeous adult male, was foraging with a large mixed flock 
(titmice, Cassin's, Plumbeous, & Hutton's Vireos, Black-throated Gray and 
Orange-crowned Warblers, White-breasted Nuthatches, Ruby-crowned Kinglets, 
loads of Chipping Sparrows) in the willows and cottonwoods south of the river 
along the Anza Trail right where the trail first comes along right next to the 
water - about 250-300 yards south of the bridge on the west side of the river. 


It was otherwise slow, but I did happen upon a vocal CASSIN'S KINGBIRD just 
south of the little sewage pond south of the bridge, a single WHITE-WINGED DOVE 
at the bridge, and I had what was surely Diane Touret's big flock of CHIHUAHUAN 
RAVENS in the same general area as the kingbird. Numbers of RUFOUS-WINGED 
SPARROWS along the trail were pretty impressive, too. 


Just a 'heads up', it would be interesting to know the race the lowland reports 
of Eastern Bluebird that are starting to trickle in. The only lowland s.e. AZ 
specimens are of the nominate (i.e. - out of state) race, so if you see any 
Easterns in the lowlands, it would be good to note the race (of course, a photo 
would be nice, too!). 


Good birding,
 
Dave Stejskal
Field Guides Inc.
www.fieldguides.com
800-728-4953
Subject: Re: AZ:11/06/09:Fort Lowell Park Magnolia Warbler
From: Mark Stevenson <drbrdr AT WORLDNET.ATT.NET>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 14:29:12 -0700
Sharp-eyed Morgan Jackson relocated the MAGNOLIA WARBLER in the cottonwoods at 
the east end of Cottonwood Lane in Fort Lowell Park around 1 PM. Cliff Cathers 
and John Yerger obtained photos of the bird. 


A flock of Cedar Waxwings flew over later.

Thanks to Cliff and Darlene for a great bird.

Good birding,
Mark Stevenson
Tucson, AZ

PS Cottonwood Lane is the double row of cottonwoods stretching from Craycroft 
Road to the ruins of the old fort hospital. 

Subject: AZ: Boyce Thompson Arboretum 11/06/09 TWO Rufous-backed Robins
From: Richard Ditch <richditch AT EARTHLINK.NET>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 12:35:18 -0700
I was surprised to find TWO Rufous-backed Robins in view at the same  
time this morning 11/06/09 in a tree with purple fruit in the Rose  
Garden near the Smith building at Boyce Thompson Arboretum. Sorry, no  
photos.

Also present feeding at this spot: American Robin, Cedar Waxwing,  
Hermit Thrush, Curve-billed Thrasher, Crissal Thrasher, Verdin, Gila  
Woodpecker, Northern Mockingbird, and Phainopepla.

Crissal Thrasher also continues in and under the Chinese Pistachio  
tree opposite the east end of the Herb Garden.

A few Western Bluebirds were flycatching in the more open areas in  
the eucalyptus area near the white footbridge.

No sign of the bobcat.

Rich Ditch
Phoenix

web site: www.richditch.com
photo blog: richditch.wordpress.com
Subject: SEAZ: Sweetwater - Golden-crowned Sparrow, Bona"parted"-Gulls, Tennesse Warbler
From: Molly Pollock <mollymp AT FLASH.NET>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 12:25:04 -0700
Hello Birders,

This morning, I refound Jake's GOLDEN-CROWNED SPARROW, on the berm, in a 
mesquite tree, between the Santa Cruz River and the Sweetwater recharge basins. 
We parked near the corner of Commerce and Riverpark and walked northwest along 
the riverbank. Just before we reached the end of the second recharge basin, I 
spotted the sparrow sitting atop a mesquite where it stayed until a Cactus Wren 
chased it into the middle of a closer mesquite. It stayed in the area long 
enough for Diana Touret, Jerry Bock, Mark and I to have nice looks. 


Dick Palmer later spotted 2 BONAPARTE GULLS in the second basin as you count 
from the east. Mark and I hurried to the location just in time to enjoy them 
for a few minutes before they departed down river. 


The TENNESSEE WARBLER continues to delight many in the northwest corner of 
Sweetwater. It moved around from the mesquite that has a bat house in the 
middle of it, to the salt bush next to the path, to the cottonwood tree along 
the marsh a little further east, then to one of the islands in the marsh. 


As we were leaving, the Hutton's Vireo scolded us, along the cement path 
between the restrooms and the first bridge. 


Good Birding,

Molly Pollock
Tucson, AZ
Subject: AZ:11/06/09:Fort Lowell Park Magnolia Warbler
From: "Clifford A. Cathers" <AZCLIFFY AT Q.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 12:08:31 -0700
Darlene Smyth and I were out this gorgeous Friday morning leisurely birding 
a few of Tucson's green patches when we stumbled upon a nice first fall 
male MAGNOLIA WARBLER in the row of cottonwoods stretching from the parking 
area to Craycroft Road at Fort Lowell Park at 10:45 AM today.  It was 
initially in the 10th cottonwood on the right of the path as you face 
Craycroft Road.

The bird first caught our attention with the bright yellow breast and dark 
side streaking.  The tellow belly transitions to white undertail coverts 
and a partially white tail.  The tail provided the best clues, with white 
undertail coverts contrasting with a dark set of tail tips (very straight 
abrupt transition from a white tail to dark tail tips across the underside 
of the tail).  The clincher was seeing faint white notches or squares on 
the upper tail surface.  The bird has two white wingbars, slatish gray 
head, a yellowish throat, white eyerings, greenish gray upper back without 
obvious streaks and a light yellowish-gray cast to a patch across the 
throat.  Unfortunately we did not view the yellow rump.

There were also WESTERN BLUEBIRDs in the park.  Earlier at McCormick Park 
we found the RED-BREASTED SAPSUCKER, thanks to Richard Laskey (thanks!).  
And even earlier, we had a flock of 15-20 WESTERN BLUEBIRDs in Molino Basin 
in the lower part of the Santa Catalinas.

I'm heading back to Fort Lowell Park to try to get pictures.  Good luck if 
you try for this nice eastern bird.

Clifford A. Cathers
Economy Birding Services, Inc.
"Quality Birding With Your Budget in Mind"
http://www.economybirding.com
Budget Bird Guiding for the Desert Southwest
AZCliffy AT q.com
Subject: 2 cents on The Template--last?
From: D Wall <yogi1 AT NPGCABLE.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 11:54:24 -0700
I have to wonder: As the original requester for the rigid dating  
system is a bird guide, is the template being pushed so aggressively  
to facilitate the guide business? If so, it's an inappropriate  
request. We're not here for that. If it's truly in the selfless  
interest of science, I guess anyone has a right to ask. Which still  
doesn't mean we're required to obey under threat of public censure. I  
was particularly miffed to see people identified by name for their  
"transgressions." That was over-the-top rude, in my opinion. Apologies  
are in order.

I too am bugged by this demand to follow someone's template if I want  
to post. I'd just as soon skip it as risk getting browbeaten for doing  
it "wrong." That said, it's nice to know when and where a bird is  
spotted. I don't see that there's been a big problem, though. But  
then, I'm only in it for the joy.

My best regards to all you wunnerful birdfolk, even those who might  
get a little presumptuous on occasion.

Dennis Wall
Flagstaff
Subject: SE AZ: 11/06/09 - SPRNCA Louisiana Waterthrush
From: Stuart Healy <stuarthealy AT COX.NET>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 11:26:05 -0700
San Pedro Riparian National Conservation Area
Friday, November 6, 2009

I found a LOUISIANA WATERTHRUSH along the river this morning.
It was in the section south of where the trail from the San Pedro House
meets the river. Specifically, 80 yards south of trail marker #7.
The water is very shallow here and conditions are ideal for the bird.
A Louisiana Waterthrush has wintered in the same general area since 2003.

My attention was drawn to the bird by its loud call and it continued to
call over the 15 minute period that I observed it, starting around 9:30am.

I checked Kingfisher Pond, Black Phoebe Pond and a one mile stretch
of the river without seeing or hearing the Green Kingfisher (last reported 
10/29). 


Generally, birding was very slow and I only managed 43 species. The least
common species for this location were GREAT EGRET and HUTTON'S VIREO.

HAMMOND'S & DUSKY FLYCATCHERS were along the river.

Stuart

Stuart Healy, Western U.S. Bird Guide,
Specializing in SE Arizona and the White Mountains.
Personal Guiding and Custom Tours; 
220 Stardust St., Sierra Vista, AZ 85635.
(520) 458-7603 mailto:stuarthealy AT cox.net
http://www.aztrogon.com
Birding journal: http://www.aztrogon.com/journal/Main.htm
Subject: ABQ merlin - UNM area
From: Rob Yaksich <grobyak AT YAHOO.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 10:00:07 -0800
Hi all - I'm doing some long-term house-sitting in the UNM North Campus area, 
and yesterday (11/5) at about 4:15pm, I spotted a merlin perched in a mostly 
dead elm/ash in a yard on Columbia between Constitution and Mountain (a block 
east of the Law School). I don't know how long it had been there, but seemed 
quite at ease. Nice and pale like a Richardson's/Great Plains. 


Saw one of the San Antonio Ave. peregrines today (Fri, 11/6) near the post 
office. 

Rob
   
"By His stripes, we are healed." - Isaiah 53




      
Subject: mark your calendars Nov. 27, 2009
From: Wezil Walraven <byrdguide AT YAHOO.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 09:46:46 -0800
During the Thanksgiving week (Nov. 23 through the 29), my wife Lisa and I will 
be in Southeast Arizona. I will be guiding that week, for those of you 
interested in my guiding services. 


Lisa will be displaying her new bird art at the Casa de San Pedro on November 
27th only, from noon- 5pm. 8933 S. Yell Herford, AZ, off Palominas Rd, mile 
marker 2. In addition to artwork there will be smaller hand crafted gift items 
available, perfect for holiday shopping. 


We are hoping to catch up with old friends, clients and acquaintances. 
 Wezil Walraven
Wezil Walraven Bird Tours LLC
Senior Guide for High Lonesome Bird Tours
specializing in birds of the Southwest & Mexico
125 Summer Haven Road
Swannanoa, NC 28778
toll free 888-577-0433
home (828)581-4592
byrdguide AT yahoo.com
www.wrensandravens.com



      
Subject: Re: NO SIGHTINGS: 2 (more) cents on dating controversy
From: vivian mac kinnon <arcvivian AT YAHOO.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 08:52:56 -0800
Howdy Birdsters,

OK, I usually to stay out of these things as I'd rather be birding... 

BUT, bottom line is I don't want this sort of 
thing/discussion/rants/finger-pointing to STOP people from posting. We all 
learn who-to-read, who-not-to-read, and have different opinions on how to post, 
etc. 


Using my prerogative, I comply with reasonable requests, especially if it is 
somebody trying to use my info for some/any sort of data collecting, as I hate 
collecting/entering/compiling data - god-dog bless them for it, especially when 
they share! 


My request is simple, please don't let any of this stuff stop you from posting 
your sightings! I recently met a gal that thought she saw a Philly Vireo at Ft. 
Lowell Park but was afraid to post it to us...we're too scary and there's so 
much "e-blood" flowing...crap! Now the bird is gone and we'll never know... 


Make your own rules but please, please, please, keep posting...um, bird 
sightings that is. 


Going birding now, hope you will too!
Virtual Vivian




--- On Fri, 11/6/09, Myron L. Scott  wrote:

> From: Myron L. Scott 
> Subject: [BIRDWG05] NO SIGHTINGS:  2 cents on dating controversy
> To: BIRDWG05 AT LISTSERV.ARIZONA.EDU
> Date: Friday, November 6, 2009, 8:55 AM
> Seems to me:
> 
>      Every few months there's a new
> spasm of demands for all posters to adopt a specific posting
> format:
>  
>       Put the state - and maybe even the
> County - in the Subject line;
>       Put the species -  at least of
> rarities - in the Subject line;
>       Use the four-word abbreviations for
> species;
>       DON'T use the four-word
> abbreviations;
>       Always include a species' scientific
> (Latin) name; 
>       Always post directions;
>       Don't post directions if someone else
> already has posted them or if they're available online or in
> the latest edition of the SE Az, NM or other site guide;
>       Never advocate, even if the advocacy
> directly relates to birds;
>       Never post anything but sightings;
>       If a post contains no sighting report,
> so indicate in Subject line (I actually agree with that
> one);
>       Never use a narrative style;
>       Put the date in the text body (even
> though it always appears on the Date line of the e-mail
> caption).  
> 
> I even seem to recall a brief but intense discussion of
> whether to use only GPS coordinates to i.d. location - or,
> of course, to never use such data.  
> 
> 
>      I'll allow that the Date line of
> an e-mail caption is not a perfect alternative to dates in
> text and that all posters should consider that fact, if
> text-dating advocates will acknowledge that life is too
> short for endless debate about rigid but unenfocrable
> posting rules - expecially since most such proposed rules
> have the obvious effect of saving the proponent a bit of
> time, thought or trouble at the cost of burdening all other
> posters.  
> 
> 
>      One wonders how many of the
> authors of such proposals have the patience birding
> requires.   It leaves me imagining a taxonomy
> of such new rule proponents:
> ADD?   HADD?  Authoritarian
> Personalities (see T.W. Adorno)?  remote control
> addicts?  victims of excessive channel surfing? 
> micro-bloggers?  people stuck in the first stage of the
> Freudian schema of sexual development?  Bureaucrats?
> Lawyers???
> 
> Myron Scott
> (Attorney at Law)
> Tempe, AZ
> 



Subject: Miller House of Mesa Possible Male Magnificent Hummer 11-6
From: Jay Miller <arizonajay23 AT COX.NET>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 08:12:36 -0800
This morning I saw a large hummer with a green throat, but my pictures show a 
mostly green belly and some rufous in the tail. It stopped to catch some nats 
at the top of one of my trees, but I think I saw it at my feeder the other day. 
Better keep that feeder full. I sent some pixs to Mike Moore to get some ID 
help because it doesn't fit nicely as a Magnificent but I don't know what else 
it could be. 


Jay Miller
Mesa, AZ
Subject: NO SIGHTINGS: 2 cents on dating controversy
From: "Myron L. Scott" <gaia_3 AT NETZERO.NET>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 15:55:05 GMT
Seems to me:

 Every few months there's a new spasm of demands for all posters to adopt a 
specific posting format: 

 
      Put the state - and maybe even the County - in the Subject line;
      Put the species -  at least of rarities - in the Subject line;
      Use the four-word abbreviations for species;
      DON'T use the four-word abbreviations;
      Always include a species' scientific (Latin) name; 
      Always post directions;
 Don't post directions if someone else already has posted them or if they're 
available online or in the latest edition of the SE Az, NM or other site guide; 

      Never advocate, even if the advocacy directly relates to birds;
      Never post anything but sightings;
 If a post contains no sighting report, so indicate in Subject line (I actually 
agree with that one); 

      Never use a narrative style;
 Put the date in the text body (even though it always appears on the Date line 
of the e-mail caption). 


I even seem to recall a brief but intense discussion of whether to use only GPS 
coordinates to i.d. location - or, of course, to never use such data. 



 I'll allow that the Date line of an e-mail caption is not a perfect 
alternative to dates in text and that all posters should consider that fact, if 
text-dating advocates will acknowledge that life is too short for endless 
debate about rigid but unenfocrable posting rules - expecially since most such 
proposed rules have the obvious effect of saving the proponent a bit of time, 
thought or trouble at the cost of burdening all other posters. 



 One wonders how many of the authors of such proposals have the patience 
birding requires. It leaves me imagining a taxonomy of such new rule 
proponents: ADD? HADD? Authoritarian Personalities (see T.W. Adorno)? remote 
control addicts? victims of excessive channel surfing? micro-bloggers? people 
stuck in the first stage of the Freudian schema of sexual development? 
Bureaucrats? Lawyers??? 


Myron Scott
(Attorney at Law)
Tempe, AZ
Subject: Interesting woodpeckers - Santa Cruz near Tumacocori, AZ
From: Diane Touret <dctouret AT COMCAST.NET>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 06:05:59 -0700
Yesterday (11/5) I tried and failed again to find the Rose-throated Becard 
at Santa Gertrudis Lane, but was compensated by quite a woodpecker show in 
the burnt area north of the crossing on the east side. There were at least 6 
and probably many more N. Flickers and several Gila and Ladder-backed 
Woodpeckers. But the best sighting was a male WILLIAMSON'S SAPSUCKER found 
by Sally Johnsen and her friend. As soon as we all got on to it, another 
black woodpecker flew in directly below it - a LEWIS' WOODPECKER! And there 
were at least 2 Red-naped Sapsuckers, one along the river and the other in 
the hedgerow.  Also seen were both Eastern and Western Bluebirds, Cedar 
Waxwings, a pair of Inca Doves (but no Ruddy Ground-Doves), the Crissal 
Thrasher (under the pyracantha), and from 80-100 Chihuahuan Ravens heading 
north in 2 large flocks about mid-day.    Diane Touret  (Tucson,AZ) 
Subject: AZFO - New photos: Rose-throated Becard, Rufous-backed Robin, Tennessee Warbler, Golden-crowned Sparrow, Chestnut-sided Warbler
From: Mike Moore <mcmoore32 AT GMAIL.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 05:02:24 -0700
Field Ornithologists,
   
Matthew Brooks submitted photos taken by Paul Suchanek of the Tumacacori
Rose-throated Becard and the Tubac Chestnut-sided Warbler, Andrew Core
submitted photos of the Sweetwater Tennessee Warbler and Golden-crowned
Sparrow, and Moez Ali contributed photos of the Patagonia Rufous-backed
Robin.   Thanks Matthew, Paul, Andrew and Moez!

Thanks to all who use the online form below to submit photos.  It makes my
job a lot easier and ensures your photos will be posted more quickly.  

Photos posted at:
 
http://www.azfo.org
click on "Photo Documentation"
   
Arizona Field Ornithologists welcomes Arizona rarity photo contributions
from all photographers throughout the state.  

Use our online form to submit photos:
http://www.azfo.org/gallery/PhotoContribution.html

If you enjoy the photo web site, please consider joining AZFO and supporting
our other activities.  Details on the web site.

We strive for accuracy.  Please email any corrections to postings to me.

Mike Moore
AZFO Photo Editor
Subject: NM: Dated Ladder-Backed Woodpecker Sandoval Co
From: Rick K <rickkoehler AT GMAIL.COM>
Date: Fri, 6 Nov 2009 01:15:58 -0700
We have been graced with a very vociferous Ladder-Backed Woodpecker (male) 
for the past week or so. Remarkable in that our specific area is largely 
sagebrush with scant trees, and only one LBWO has been noted during the 
seven years we've been here. It "chips" up a storm as it samples our suet 
feeder, and has provided good company as I worked nearby on days off.

I must also note that I was rather awe-struck by the "dateless" post, both 
in the fact that someone has decided to make an issue of this, and carried 
it so far as to single out people who are valued contributors to the list. 
Way to go.

In an effort to comply with the imperial directive, I have included a date 
for one of the sightings: the 1F (hexadecimal) day of the 1010th (binary) 
month in the year 3731 (octal).


<")
(  \
""\\___

Rick Koehler
Subject: AZ: Tucson Parks--05 Nov 09
From: Erika Wilson <terika88 AT COX.NET>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 20:39:06 -0700
AZ: Tucson Parks--05 Nov 09

Picked up my birding friend Bettie Harriman at the airport early this
afternoon for a ten-day birding visit. After lunch we decided to visit
McCormick Park, so this list supplements the Potmus list posted earlier today.

We had fine views of the RED-BREASTED SAPSUCKER in the southeast corner of
the park, which was our target bird. Also of interest were: a small flock of
Western Bluebirds (8), Vermilion Flycatchers (1 male & 1 female), the same
Eastern Meadowlarks (3), and a Red-tailed Hawk being chased by a male Am.
Kestrel.

Next we went to Seneca & Ridgeway to look for the Short-tailed Hawk--no luck
during our watch (3:30-4:45 p.m.), but by the time we left there were at
least six other birders there to carry on. While waiting, we saw Gambel's
Quail (6), a Cooper's Hawk chasing a Gila Woodpecker, a male Red-naped
Sapsucker, a pair of Am. Kestrels, and a "Red-shafted" N. Flicker, plus an
assortment of species found in residential neighborhoods.

Cheers, Erika Wilson (Sierra Vista, AZ)
Subject: Black-chinned Hummingbird in Tucson
From: Rich Hoyer <birdernaturalist AT ME.COM>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 20:06:28 -0700
November 5, 2009

Hi Birders,

I have a BLACK-CHINNED HUMMINGBIRD coming to my north-central Tucson  
feeders, which I first noticed yesterday. As far as I know, this  
species is unrecorded in SE Arizona in November – which makes it  
statistically as likely as Ruby-throated this time of year. So,  
knowing the history of the feeders in this yard, the first thing I  
looked for was a leg band. Seeing no band, the rather long bill,  
grayish forecrown, and dark smudge on the side of the neck, I  
concluded that it was indeed not a Ruby-throat. I waited around quite  
a bit yesterday off an on, poised to get photos, but after the 8:55  
a.m sighting I only heard it briefly in the late afternoon. Today, it  
appeared at the feeder just outside my bedroom/office window in the  
late afternoon, and I managed a digibinned photo (holding my little  
point-and-shoot up to my binoculars). I posted the photo to my  
Facebook account here: 
http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?pid=2993160&l=02a505caa1&id=650508276 

.

In the meantime, waiting for the bird to appear yesterday, I snapped a  
few photos of the many Anna's Hummingbirds coming to the feeders. And  
to my surprise I found that at least three of them were wearing metal  
bands. If we ever find out where and when these birds were banded,  
I'll pass on the word. I've looked for banded hummingbird off and on  
over the 11 1/2 years that I've lived here, and I've never noticed one  
(except for the Ruby-throated that Sheri Williamson banded and which  
stayed for for more than 3 months afterward).

We have 10 feeders on the property, but my landlords have been  
maintaining only 3 continuously since I have mostly been traveling  
since mid-August. I returned from Peru on Monday and filled the  
remaining 7 feeders on Tuesday, and it's already busy out there.

Yesterday I also had a nice female Townsend's Warbler in the yard, my  
second or third here.

Good Birding,

Rich

P.S. If you're interested in how the birding and natural history was  
in Peru, please feel free to check out my blog, in the signature below.
---
Rich Hoyer
Tucson, Arizona
http://birdernaturalist.blogspot.com/

Senior Leader for WINGS
http://wingsbirds.com
---
Subject: Tucson parks 11.5
From: Bev Postmus <bpostmus AT COX.NET>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 19:46:45 -0700
Today Clair, Karen and I birded some of the parks in Tucson starting with C. 
Columbus park where we had many dark-eyed juncos, many yellow-rumps, several 
Abert's towhees, a roadrunner and a Harris's hawk down near the river. No 
Lawrence's goldfinch. We checked the little garden at the Wild Birds Unlimited 
store to find the fox sparrow had been there an hour before our arrival. Next: 
McCormick Park where we watched three meadowlarks feeding on the ground as we 
ate lunch. We walked over to the swings area and apparently flushed up the 
red-breasted sapsucker who flew to several small deciduous trees on its way to 
the dense pines closer to the play area. It then went on to the trees along the 
parking lot and spent much time making some pretty nice holes in the last 
small, leafy tree to the south (next to a palm tree.) We had great looks at it. 
Then on to Ft. Lowell Park where we hoped for the wood duck but no luck. There 
were many wigeons and a number of ring-necked ducks and an interestingly 
colored immature male vermillion flycatcher. Then to Reid Park where we looked 
for the Lewis's woodpecker but didn't find it. Across from the very northwest 
corner of the park we had 5 Harris's hawks, one feeding on a squirrel. It''s 
really fun to park-hop for many hours of pleasant birding. Bev Postmus, Green 
Vallley. 

Subject: AZ: Kiwanis Park, Tempe, 4 Nov 2009 - Clark's Grebe continues
From: Bobby Metz <bwmetz AT GMAIL.COM>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 19:24:36 -0700
Just wanted to post that the Clark's Grebe continued at Kiwanis Park in Tempe 
as of 12:30 PM yesterday. As Jim already noted, I didn't observed it eating 
anything though it dove a dozen or so time while I was there. Nothing else out 
of ordinary: 


Full List
-------------------------------
Great-tailed Grackle
Mourning Dove
Ring-necked Duck
Lesser Scaup
American Coot
Mallard
Clark's Grebe

Note: The path around the lake is blocked on the NE corner so if you start from 
the southern entrance, be prepared to double back if you walk the eastern 
shore. 


Bobby
Subject: AZ: Rufous-backed Robin at Boyce Thompson Arboretum near Superior, 11/5
From: Susan Birky <snbbirky AT YAHOO.COM>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 17:44:43 -0800
We (Barbara Koenig, Judy Edison and I)saw the Rufous-backed Robin this morning 
at about 9:15 in the tree in the rose garden with the deep purple berries 
mentioned in an earlier post. 


We continued on to Oak Flat Campground where we saw one each Mountain Bluebird, 
Western Bluebird, and Cassin's Vireo. There was a lot of bird activity around 
the campground but nothing else that wasn't expected (we DID NOT see any 
Juniper Titmice). 



Susan Birky
Tucson






      
Subject: AZ: Madera Canyon - Black-capped Gnatcatcher & Yellow-bellied Sapsucker again
From: Laurens Halsey <desert-harrier AT COX.NET>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 18:41:39 -0700
The BLACK-CAPPED GNATCATCHERs continued at the Proctor Road area of Madera
Canyon this morning (11/5/09).  The first two were near the bend on the
paved trail as it heads down towards the road as direct sunlight began
reaching the vegetation (08:15), just one call alerted us to their presence.
The second two, one of which appeared to be an adult male, were near the bat
houses further up the trail at 09:00.  The second two were calling back and
forth continuously during our ten minute observation, and one was
photographed.  Whether there were two or four individuals involved today is
difficult to say.  A Blue-gray Gnatcatcher was seen and heard behind the
Whitehouse Picnic area.  Western Bluebirds continue though not is as great
numbers as Tuesday (11/3/09), no Easterns.  Two Sharp-shinned Hawks were
hunting in the area of the waterfall (presently just damp) below the (dry)
stream/road crossing; one which while probably horrifying the smaller birds
graced us with prolonged close range perched views.  A YELLOW-BELLIED
SAPSUCKER was observed in a sycamore above the feeding station at Madera
Kubo.  This bird was competing for a set of sap wells high in the tree with
two Red-naped Sapsuckers.  A quick look at my distant, poorly lit
photographs  .. can't see any distinguishing features.  The nearby
Pyracantha bush is nearly devoid of berries.  The highlight of the day
according to my guests from Victoria, Canada was the very cooperative
Painted Redstart at the Madera Picnic Area.

Laurens

 

Laurens Halsey

www.desertharrier.com

desert-harrier AT cox.net

 
Subject: Glendale Recharge Ponds, 5 November 2009
From: Tommy DeBardeleben <sunsfan1331 AT AOL.COM>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 18:32:18 -0700
Hey everyone,

Justin Jones and I spent a few hours birding the Glendale Recharge Ponds, 
with several good highlights.

The main highlight were a pair of BLACK VULTURES, which were first sitting 
in the southwestern most basin/pond.  They have never been seen at this 
location before.  Possibly a little out of the birds normal range.

Another good highlight was a small group of 3 DUNLINS, which were present 
along the shore of the middle north pond.  

WATERFOWL: Abundant numbers!

Other notables:

Western Grebe
Eared Grebe
Buffleheads
Canvasbacks
Redheads
female Hooded Merganser
Gadwall
Osprey 
Peregrine Falcon
Cooper's Hawk
Spotted Sandpiper


On another note, I was here last night (didn't post) and I had a WILSON'S 
SNIPE, which I've never seen in any previous visits.  It was a no show 
tonight however.

Good birding,
Tommy DeBardeleben (Glendale, Arizona)
http://www.arizonagoshawk.com/
Subject: SEAZ: Sweetwater Wetlands Golden-crowned Sparrow and others - 11/5/09
From: Jake Mohlmann <mohlmann2 AT YAHOO.COM>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 15:57:27 -0800
birders-

 I spent from 7:00 to about 12:30 at Sweetwater Wetlands in Tucson this 
morning. The highlight was a 1st-year looking GOLDEN-CROWNED SPARROW in the 
river proper near the southwest corner of the complex at about 9:30a.m. 


The TENNESSEE WARBLER also continued in the northwest corner of the complex 
just east of the northwestern-most cottonwood tree in the atriplex (shrub) row. 
It perched in a mesquite for good views. 


photos of the sparrow posted at www.adventurebirding.blogspot.com

Other interesting birds:

common raven - flock of 7 flew over
hutton's vireo - near hidden pond
spotted towhee - near hidden pond
cedar waxwings - flew over
wilson's warbler - only 1
bewick's wren - 2 together within the wetlands
chipping sparrow - 10 in river
bufflehead - middle recharge basin
snowy egret - western recharge basin
black-necked stilt - 9 in recharge basins

A total of 93 species were tallied when I left. Definitely missed enough 
'getable' birds to push it over 100 if I would have stayed longer... maybe next 
time! 


cheers,

Jake Mohlmann
Tucson, AZ
www.adventurebirding.com


      
Subject: FW: Tucson Hooded Mergansers
From: Mark Stevenson <drbrdr AT WORLDNET.ATT.NET>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 15:54:47 -0700
From the Tucson Audubon Society's RBA voice mail at 520-798-1005 X1

John Higgins reports 3 HOODED MERGANSERS in the smaller/upper pond (north of 
the probation office) at Sam Lena Park this afternoon. 


Thanks to John for the report.

Happy Birding,
Mark Stevenson
Tucson, AZ
Subject: SE AZ: Green Valley WWTP - 5 Nov 09
From: Michael Marsden <birdanza AT COX.NET>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 15:18:56 -0700
Among the 32 species at the Green Valley WWTP this morning were:
  6 Redheads,
  3 Buffleheads,
  12 Lesser Scaup,
 4 Greater Scaup (by themselves on deep-water lagoon 2B; all seemed to be 
juvs/1st winters; very flighty - helpfully as they all clearly showed their 
bright white wing-bars extending to the wing tips), 

  8 Long-billed Dowitchers (now in their 5th week) and
  1 Eastern Bluebird (the first sighting I know of here).

For the 2nd continuous week there were no Killdeers. 

Full list on www.eBird.org

  
Michael Marsden
(520) 269-6240
Green Valley, AZ
Subject: Patagonia AZ at Spirit Tree Inn Rufous-backed Robin
From: Spirit Tree Inn B & B <Spiritreeinn AT AOL.COM>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 16:12:19 EST
A rufous-backed robin was seen at Spirit Tree Inn B & B on November 5,  
2009 at 1:00 pm in the pyracantha bush.  It was eating the red  berries.
 
 
Mary Jane,  Tom & Joe
Spirit Tree Inn Bed & Breakfast
3 Harshaw Creek  Rd
Patagonia Arizona 85624
1-866-394-0121 toll free #
1/520-401-0541  Verizon cell  #
www.spirittreeinn.com
Subject: Am. Crow near the San Pedro, Steller's Jay in Stump Canyon
From: Peter Sockness <savetheriver AT COX.NET>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 13:39:28 -0700
Greetings,
This morning (11/5/09) I did some hiking near the San Pedro River just 
south of Hereford Rd. and on the west side of the river. I parked at the 
BLM parking area and walked south along a large cut field that was full of 
Meadowlarks, both Eastern and Western as far as I could determine. There 
were also many ravens flying about and feeding in the field and with them 
was at least one AMERICAN CROW (this could be one of the crows that Gordon 
Lewis posted seeing a couple of weeks ago). The crow was feeding very near 
one of the ravens so I got a nice size comparison. Also seen were quite 
large numbers of sparrows: White-crowned, chipping, Brewer's, Lincoln, 
Vesper, Savanah, Song and Black-Throated. Down near the river were some 
Dark-Eyed Juncos and Yellow-Rumped Warblers and a few Say's Phoebes. While 
in the cottonwoods I heard one quick and loud raptor call and then the hawk 
flew out of a cottonwood and headed north along the edge of the field. I 
never got a very good look but it sure looked like a GRAY HAWK. Other 
raptors included American Kestrel, male and female Northern Harrier and Red-
Tailed hawk.
Yesterday (11/4)in our yard here in Lower Stump Canyon in the southern 
Huachucas we had a STELLER'S JAY, who was back this morning for more 
goodies. In seven years here in Stump Canyon that is only the second 
Steller's we have seen in the yard, which is at about 5000'.

Pete Sockness
Hereford, AZ
Subject: Re: Dateless in BIRDWG05 land, 5 November 2009
From: Tommy DeBardeleben <sunsfan1331 AT AOL.COM>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 12:17:29 -0700
Stuart,

People like you take the fun out of birding.

Obviously you have too much time on your hands to look at all this.  Who 
really cares if someone leaves out a date.  This is supposed to be a fun 
thing among birders, not a statistic about listserve "date logics".  

Lets do get back to birding!

Tommy DeBardeleben
Glendale, Arizona
Subject: se AZ: Tucson Sweetwater Golden-crowned Sparrow
From: Andrew Core <andrewcore AT GMAIL.COM>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 12:07:46 -0700
Hi all,

I first want to say thanks to Jake for finding the bird and getting me on it
- I was over at Columbus Park looking at Western Bluebirds (no grebes
there).  It definitely looks like a first-year Golden-crowned Sparrow to me
- yellow on the top of the head, gray face.  Between us I think we got some
definitive pictures.

I've made a quick little map to show the bird's location here:
http://bit.ly/W11Uz

I parked near the corner of Commerce and Riverpark and walked northwest
along the riverbank to a long ramp that drops down into the riverbed.  The
last 5-6 feet down are definitely steep, and I don't know of an easier way
to get down.  If you don't take the ramp it's about 45 feet down at a 60
degree angle.

You could possibly see this bird without going all the way down into the
river, but I imagine it would take a good deal of patience.  It was tame,
allowing us to approach (quietly) to within 10 feet or so, but very tough to
get a good look at.  It sat in the middle of the bush for quite a while.
The last we saw of it, it flew another 20 yards downstream (north) and we
did not pursue it.

Another word of warning - Jake spotted a BIG rattlesnake (4+ feet long) just
a yard or two from his feet as we were trying to get pictures of the bird.
It was moving and Jake actually heard it getting closer... Yikes!

good birding,
Andrew


date below

On Thu, Nov 5, 2009 at 10:03 AM, Andrew Core  wrote:

> Jake Mohlmann found a possible Golden-crowned Sparrow in the riverbed
> southeast of Sweetwater this morning (11/5). Jake and I are trying to get
> pix.
>
> Andrew
>
> -
>
> Andrew Core
> Tucson, AZ - sent from phone
>



-- 


Andrew Core
Tucson, AZ
Subject: AZ, 5 Nov 09: Patagonia Gray Hawk, Western Tanager
From: Matt Brown <mattbrownbirds AT GMAIL.COM>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 11:48:06 -0700
Abbie Zeltzer, Patagonia's Librarian and CBC co-coordinator, just called to
say there was an adult GRAY HAWK vocalizing and circling over the library
neighborhood just now. The Library is between the Third and Fourth Street
crossings, on the east side of Route 82, on Duquesne ("Du-kane") Ave. Good
ears, Abbie!

This morning there was a late and very young WESTERN TANAGER foraging near
the Sinaloa Wren nest site. The wren was only briefly heard, too deep in to
have been anywhere near visible to me, but somewhat downstream from the
nest. There is no water in his usual territory (even at the Cut-bank) so he
may occasionally move down to the current upstream extent of exposed water,
which is near the "Upper Abutment" in the Patagonia-Sonoita Creek Preserve.
At present, he is even harder to locate than last year, when he was quite
difficult to locate. Sorry...

Matt Brown
The Patagonia Birding & Butterfly Co.
520-604-6300
mattbrownbirdsATgmailDOTcom
www.lifebirds.com (under re-construction)
Flickr photostream: http://www.flickr.com/photos/38376251 AT N07/
YouTube videos: http://www.youtube.com/user/mattbrownbirds
Subject: Fw: eBird Report - Lakeside Park, Tucson
From: Mark Stevenson <drbrdr AT WORLDNET.ATT.NET>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 11:33:21 -0700
Hi Birders,
    The results of an hour's jaunt around the park this morning. More 
interesting observations preceded by asterisks.
Mark Stevenson
Tucson, AZ
>
>
> Location:     Lakeside Park, Tucson
> Observation date:     11/5/09
> Number of species:     35
>
> Mallard
> American Wigeon     14
> Ring-necked Duck     5     brief stay
> Pied-billed Grebe     3
** Western Grebe     1     continuing
> Great Blue Heron     2
> Great Egret     1
** Osprey     1     Continuing. Dining on fish atop a light standard
> Cooper's Hawk     1
> American Coot     31
> Rock Pigeon     52
> Eurasian Collared-Dove     1
> Mourning Dove     7
> Anna's Hummingbird     3
> Gila Woodpecker     X
> Northern Flicker (Red-shafted)     1
> Say's Phoebe     1
> Vermilion Flycatcher     6
> Verdin     X
> Ruby-crowned Kinglet     1
> Black-tailed Gnatcatcher     1
** Western Bluebird     7
> Northern Mockingbird     4
> European Starling     40
> American Pipit     1
> Phainopepla     2
> Yellow-rumped Warbler (Audubon's)     9
> Abert's Towhee     2
> Lark Sparrow     11
> White-crowned Sparrow     29
> Red-winged Blackbird     6
> Brewer's Blackbird     45
> Great-tailed Grackle     55
** Bronzed Cowbird     12   mixed in with Brewer's Blackbirds  .
> House Finch     X
> Lesser Goldfinch     8
>
> This report was generated automatically by eBird v2(http://ebird.org)
> 
Subject: Re: Dateless - please skip unless particularly interested.
From: Gavin Bieber <kingbird77 AT HOTMAIL.COM>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 17:14:40 +0000
I find the recent singling out of particular birders who post sightings without 
embedding a date stamp more than slightly annoying. Every post to BirdW05 is 
stamped with a date by the listserve and is subsequently stored in the 
searchable archives by date, with the date clearly present. It does not seem to 
me to take very much effort to realise what the date of a post actually is. If 
the listowner wants to change the requirements for posting to include embedded 
dates, then fine we should have a discussion about it as a group, and then 
privately encourage people to follow the new system. Let's get back to 
birding... 


Gavin Bieber 
Kingbird77 AT hotmail.com
Tucson, AZ
Senior Leader, WINGS
www.wingsbirds.com

 		 	   		  
_________________________________________________________________
Bing brings you maps, menus, and reviews organized in one place.

http://www.bing.com/search?q=restaurants&form=MFESRP&publ=WLHMTAG&crea=TEXT_MFESRP_Local_MapsMenu_Resturants_1x1 
Subject: Se az: sweetwater possible golden-crowned sparrow
From: Andrew Core <andrewcore AT GMAIL.COM>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 10:03:12 -0700
Jake Mohlmann found a possible Golden-crowned Sparrow in the riverbed  
southeast of Sweetwater this morning (11/5). Jake and I are trying to  
get pix.

Andrew

-

Andrew Core
Tucson, AZ - sent from phone
Subject: AZ: Tucson Peregrine
From: Rick Wright <birdaz AT GMAIL.COM>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 09:16:41 -0700
Nothing earth-shattering by the standards of  this falconid paradise, but a
fine adult Peregrine flew north on First Avenue from Via Entrada yesterday
afternoon, something large, feathered, and doomed in its feet.
-- 
Rick Wright

Managing Director, WINGS
http://wingsbirds.com
http://birdaz.com, http://birdaz.com/blog
Subject: AZ: Arthur Pack Golf Course Pond
From: Philip Kline <pgkline_uk AT YAHOO.COM>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 08:03:04 -0800
7:15-7:45am, November 5, 2009 (that should satisfy the date police--at least I 
wasn't top of the list; way to go Mark). 


There was some interesting (if a little frustrating) waterfowl on the large 
pond at Arthur Pack Golf Course this morning.  Early morning is the best time 
to visit because you have the sun behind you and the golfers haven't reached 
the 18th hole yet, which runs alongside the pond.  You can still scope the pond 
from the dirt road on the east side of the 18th hole if there are golfers 
present (stay well back though).  


An Aechmophorus Grebe was actively diving near the middle of the pond.  It had 
a clear white patch in front of the eye and the beak was tending more towards 
the orange end of the yellow spectrum than the green end, but the dark line 
down the back of the neck was quite thick and there was not a lot of lighter 
gray on the flanks.  I concluded that it was most likely a Western, but I'm not 
certain. 


Another nice surprise was a female Hooded Merganser, which covered an amazing 
amount of territory while I was present (I only ever saw one bird).  They must 
be fast swimmers/divers.  Blue-winged and Green-winged Teal and Gadwall were 
also present.  There was also one each of Great Blue Heron and Great Egret. 


Last, was a female-type Scaup, which I think was probably a Lesser, but it 
seemed to have a very large, bulky bill with lots of white at its base.  The 
head profile seemed closer to Lesser though and when it partially stretched out 
it's wing, I did not see any white in the primaries, although this could have 
been obscured.  An interesting bird anyway. 


If anyone gets out there, I'd be interested in their opinion of the Grebe and 
the Scaup. 


Good birding,

Philip Kline



Subject: AZ: Sulphur Springs Valley White-tailed Kite, Nov. 4, 2009, 1145
From: Glenn Klingler <alala70 AT HOTMAIL.COM>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 15:57:40 +0000
Yesterday, there was a White-tailed Kite on the east side of Hwy. 191, between 
Mile Posts 14 and 15, perched on a yucca right next to the Hwy. It gave very 
nice views. 


 

Glenn Klingler

Wildlife Biologist

Elfrida, AZ
 		 	   		  
_________________________________________________________________
Bing brings you maps, menus, and reviews organized in one place.

http://www.bing.com/search?q=restaurants&form=MFESRP&publ=WLHMTAG&crea=TEXT_MFESRP_Local_MapsMenu_Resturants_1x1 
Subject: Yuma, AZ - 4 Nov 09, Golden-crowned Kinglet & Thick-billed Kingbird
From: Henry Detwiler <henrydetwiler AT EARTHLINK.NET>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 07:56:20 -0700
Greetings Birders!

Yesterday morning I found a beautiful Golden-crowned Kinglet outside of our 
glass Bureau of Reclamation entry way. It must have just collided with a 
window, since neither the local skunk nor cats had made off with it. 


Late yesterday afternoon I stopped at the Yuma Main Drain, and was rewarded by 
the squeaking of the Thick-billed Kingbird, returned for yet another winter 
season. Although I could not see the bird up at the top of the cottonwood, its 
call is quite distinctive, and it called almost continuously for about a minute 
as the sun was setting. 


Good birding,
Henry Detwiler
www.Southwestbirders.com
928-210-6474
Subject: Dateless in BIRDWG05 land
From: Stuart Healy <stuarthealy AT COX.NET>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 07:50:04 -0700
Since I raised the awareness about including a date in posts at 
the end of the first week of October, many birders have responded.
However, many have not.

The archives show 370 posts to BIRDWG05 during October week 2 to week 5.
Most were "date worthy" (see below) and of those, 127 were dateless.
FYI: 468 posts for the entire month.

13 birders contributed 3 or more dateless posts for a total of 71.

24 Stevenson, M
07 Bock, J
06 Kline, P
05 Stejskal, D
04 Lewis, G
04 Pollock, M
03 Ali, M
03 Battiste, T
03 Core, A
03 Ryan, T
03 Taylor, R
03 Weber, M
03 Wright, R 

45 birders contributed 1 or 2 dateless posts for the remaining 56.
They get a free pass this month. We all forget now and again.

What is a date worthy post?

a) Any post that reports a bird
b) Any post with an non-specific date reference (today, yesterday, Sunday,
last Tuesday) regardless of content.

Personally, I try to remember to include the date in the subject and body of 
the post. 

Both have value. 

Dates in subjects allow readers to skim through a list of subjects to pick out 
those of 

interest and allow data to be sorted easily. Some birders post the same subject 
line 

on a regular basis without a date (very naughty).

Dates in the body put the "what, where and when" of a sighting all together.
I encourage everyone to make an effort to include a date somewhere.

Let's try to do better in November (and forever).

Thanks,
Stuart

Stuart Healy, Western U.S. Bird Guide,
Specializing in SE Arizona and the White Mountains.
Personal Guiding and Custom Tours; 
220 Stardust St., Sierra Vista, AZ 85635.
(520) 458-7603 mailto:stuarthealy AT cox.net
http://www.aztrogon.com
Birding journal: http://www.aztrogon.com/journal/Main.htm
Subject: NM RBA for 11/5/09
From: Pinyonjay AT AOL.COM
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 09:24:25 EST
 
- RBA 
New  Mexico Bird Report 
November 5, 2009 
NMEX0911.05 
. 
Transcript 
. 
Hotline New Mexico 
date:  November 5, 2009 
compiler Patricia R. Snider 
Phone:  719-46-3174 
Cell  phone 505-03-107 
e-mail  address _pinyonjay AT aol.com_ (mailto:pinyonjay AT aol.com)   
. 
This is Pinyon Jay with the New Mexico Bird Report for  
November 5, 2009, sponsored by the New Mexico Ornithological  
Society.  When phone  numbers are given for private property,  
please call before going to ask for permission.  In ranch  
country do  not stray off the roads. 
. 
Highlights: Lawrence’s Goldfinch, White-tailed Kite, 
Black-capped Gnatcatcher. 
Montane  species seem to be invading the lowlands. 
A star is added for new birds to the RBA today. 
. 
. 
Places mentioned and a checklist of N.M. birds are in the N.M.  
Bird Finding Guide.  Check for earlier reports and database  
At _http://www.nmbirds.org_ (http://www.nmbirds.org/)  
or in  the archives of the AZ/NM listserve.  For photos of  
rarities and directions to some birding sites check  
_http://sites.google.com/site/oldenettelspage_ 
(http://sites.google.com/site/oldenettelspage) . 
. 
For  the Bird Records Committee and both Field Notes please  
send  reports to Dr. Sartor O. Williams, III, 119 Meadowview NW,  
Albuquerque, NM, 7104 or to  
_sunbittern AT earthlink.net_ (mailto:sunbittern AT earthlink.net) . 
. 
. 
Birds  Mentioned and Counties: 
. 
Common  Loon (*San Juan) 
Western Grebe (Chaves, Bernalillo) 
Cattle  Egret (Eddy) 
Snow  Goose (Chaves) 
Cackling Goose (Bernalillo) 
Greater Scaup (*San Juan) 
Osprey  (Eddy) 
White-tailed Kite(*Luna) 
Northern Goshawk (*Doña Ana) 
Zone-tailed Hawk (Sierra) 
Merlin  (Bernalillo, Otero, Santa Fe) 
Peregrine Falcon (Sierra) 
Prairie Falcon (Otero) 
Montezuma Quail (Hidalgo) 
Common  Moorhen (*Luna) 
Sandhill Crane (Chaves, *Curry) 
Wilson’s Snipe (Doña Ana) 
Red  Phalarope (Otero) 
Bonaparte’s Gull (Bernalillo) 
Eurasian Collared-Dove (Taos) 
Inca Dove (Hidalgo) 
Ruddy Ground-Dove (Hidalgo) 
Great Horned and Long-eared Owls (*Curry) 
Lesser Nighthawk (*Doña Ana) 
White-rhroated Swift (*Doña Ana) 
Anna’s  Hummingbird (*Doña Ana, Luna, *Hidalgo) 
Black-chinned Hummingbird (*Bernalillo) 
Broad-tailed Hummingbird (*Doña Ana) 
Rufous  Hummingbird (Santa Fe) 
Lewis’s Woodpecker (Hidalgo) 
Acorn  Woodpecker (Doña Ana) 
Yellow-bellied Sapsucker (Eddy) 
Yellow-shafted Flicker (Roosevelt) 
Eastern Phoebe (Doña Ana) 
Hutton’s Vireo (Sierra) 
Tree  Swallow (Doña Ana) 
Western Scrub-Jay (*Doña Ana) 
Mountain Chickadee (Roosevelt) 
Red-breasted Nuthatch (Doña Ana) 
Brown Creeper (Sierra) 
Golden-crowned Kinglet (Sierra, Roosevelt, Bernalillo) 
Black-capped Gnatcatcher (*Hidalgo) 
Western Bluebird (Luna, Otero, ^Doña Ana) 
Mountain Bluebird (Roosevelt, Otero) 
Townsend’s Solitaire (Bernalillo, Luna, Roosevelt 
Hermit  Trush (Doña Ana) 
American Robin (*Doña Ana) 
Gray  Catbird (Sierra) 
Sage  Thrasher (Luna) 
Bendire’s Thrasher (Valencia) 
Townsend’s Warbler (Luna) 
Sage  Sparrow (*Doña Ana) 
Fox Sparrow red (Roosevelt) 
Swamp Sparrow (Eddy) 
White-throated Sparrow (Doña Ana, *Santa Fe) 
Dark-eyed Juncos (*Doña Ana) 
Pyrrhuloxia (*Curry) 
Scott’s Oriole (Luna) 
Rosy  Finches (Bernalillo) 
Cassin’s  Finch (Roosevelt, *Bernalillo) 
Lawrence’s Goldfinch (Luna) 
Pine  Siskin and American Goldfinch (*Doña Ana) 
. 
. 
In  Bernalillo County: 
CP on November 1 had a female CASSIN’S  FINCH in her yard 
in the  Southeast Heights of Albuquerque. 
RY on October 25 had a MERLIN at Lowell  and Academy in 
Albuquerque. 
JG on October 25 at Otero Canyon south of  Tijeras found 
several GOLDEN-CROWNED KINGLETS and two TOWNSEND’S  SOLITAIRES. 
JP on October 25 saw 23 CACKLING GEESE at  the Rio Grande  
Nature  Center in Albuquerque.  CD on  October 30 reported a  
first  winter BONAPARTE’S GULL and a WESTERN GREBE at the  
center. 
BG had single female BLACK-CHINNED  HUMMINGBIRDS at his  
North  Valley feeders on October 29 through November 2. 
One feeder was put up at the Crest House  on October 27  
for  the the ROSY FINCHES, and right away two BLACKS and  
two  GRAY-CROWNED appeared, an early date. 
. 
In  Chaves County: 
JSa on the Bitter Lake Refuge near  Roswell count of October  
22  reported 66 SNOW GEESE, 10,983 SANDHILL CRANES in the area,  
and a  WESTERN GREBE. 
. 
In  Curry County: 
JLo on November 3-4 at his home in  southeast Curry Co.  
had  two LONG-EARED OWLS (photo) with a HORNED OWL, six 
PYRRHULOXIAS, and a YELLOW-SHAFTED FLICKER, with CRANES 
passing by daily.  Also there was a few cranes just west of  
the  Walmart Store in Clovis on November 3. 
. 
In  Doña Ana County: 
On October 31 JZ and MS at their home  near Radium Spings 
had an  immature GOSHAWK that may have been present for two 
weeks. 
JZ on October 20 along Hope Road in Las  Cruces found an  
ACORN  WOODPECKER (photo), five SCRUB JAYS, and a  
RED-BREASTED NUTHATCH.  In that area on November 3 DG had  
two  late LESSER NIGHTHAWKS. 
In the southern Doña Ana Mts. on November  1 DG saw four  
WHITE-THROATED SWIFTS, WESTERN BLUEBIRDS, an ANNA’S  
HUMMINGBIRD, and nine SAGE SPARROWS, 
DG at his Las Cruces home on October 25  had a WHITE-THROATED  
SPARROW, with the immature ANNA’S HUMMINGBIRD present October 21  
to 27;  two to three SCRUB JAYS and JUNCOS seen daily.  A female  
BROAD-TAILED HUMMINGBIRD was seen October 30 and a HERMIT THRUSH  
on  October 29.  The Anna’s was seen  till November 1 with the  
Broad-tailed, scrub jays, Juncos, PINE SISKINS, one AMERICAN  
GOLDFINCH were seen till November 4.  63 ROBINS were present on  
November 2. 
At Swan Pond near  Leasburg DG on October 23 found an  
EASTERN PHOEBE, up to six SNIPES, and a  TREE SWALLOW. 
. 
In  Eddy County: 
SW hiked the Delaware River south of  Malaga and recorded on 
October 31 a CATTLE EGRET and an OSPREY. 
At Rattlesnake Springs on October 24 JP,  WW, and JO had a  
YELLOW-BELLIED SAPSUCKER immature and two SWAMP SPARROWS with  
two  more sapsuckers at the adjacent Washington Ranch. 
. 
In  Hidalgo County: 
DC reported that at Rusty’s RV Park north of Rodeo on NM 
80 an  ANNA’S HUMMINGBIRD present from November 1 to 4. 
In Guadalupe Canyon on October 31 DC had  two BLACK-CAPPED 
GNATCATCHERS on the eastern half of the NM public area. 
ChB on October 27 in Clanton Canyon in the Peloncillos 
had four to six MONTEZUMA QUAIL.  He had in a flooded  
orchard 1.5 miles west of Cotton City along Church Street a  
LEWIS’S WOODPECKER, several INCA DOVES, and one RUDDY  GROUND- 
DOVE. 
County Hwy.1 south of Animas crosses the  Diamond A ( 
Gray) Ranch.  Because  of events with thoughtless birders,  
one  must NOT go off the road. 
. 
In  Luna County: 
ChB on October 26 at Pancho Villa SP near  Columbus saw  
SCOTT’S ORIOLES.  RC  and WH on October 26 had a pair of  
LAWRENCE’S GOLDFINCHES there. 
LM on October 19 and November 2 had a  MOORHEN at the Pecan  
Park  ponds in Deming.  On October 25 at  Spring Canyon State  
Park  near Deming he saw an ANNA’S HUMMINGBIRD, WESTERN BLUEBIRDS,  
TOWNSEND’S SOLITAIRES, a SAGE THRASHER, and a TOWNSEND’S  
WARBLER. 
At the Deming sewage ponds’ northwest  corner on October 30  
and  Again on November 2 LM had a WHITE-TAILED KITE. 
. 
In  Otero County: 
SW and TH on October 27 on Otero Mesa had  a suckleyi 
MERLIN  near Alamo Mt., three PRAIRIE FALCONS, MOUNTAIN and  
WESTERN BLUEBIRDS. 
JO on October 25 reported two RED  PHALAROPES at the 
main  pond of the Holloman Lakes. 
DG contacted the biologist at Holloman  AFB on the  
Holloman closures.  There is a beetle infestation at Lagoon  
G that  they are trying to rid, and they don’t want anyone  
to  spread them.  One can walk past the  gate to Stinky Lake,  
but  not drive in and can still bird there.  Contact David  
Griffin at 575-32-200 for more details. 
. 
In  Roosevelt County: 
CR on October 24 at the migrant trap west  of Melrose on  
US 60  had a red (zaboria?) FOX SPARROW, a  YELLOW-SHAFTED  
FLICKER, with MOUNTAIN CHICKADEES, GOLDEN-KINGLETS and  a 
CASSIN’S FINCH.  On  October 23 JP, WW, and JO saw a female  
MOUNTAIN BLUEBIRD, two TOWNSEND’S SOLITAIRES, and one  kinglet. 
. 
In San  Juan County: 
ChB on November 3 at Morgan Lake west of  Farmington 
saw  two GREATER SCAUPS and three COMMON LOONS. 
. 
In  Santa Fe County: 
BF had a MERLIN at the Casa Solana area  of Santa Fe on  
October 31.  
JB on October 30-31 had  a late female RUFOUS HUMMINGBIRD  
at his  Santa Fe feeders. 
At his home in north  Edgewood PN on November 3 had a 
tan-striped WHITE-THROATED  SPARROW. 
. 
In  Sierra County: 
At North Monticello Point of Elephant  Butte Lake on October 
25 RC  and WH had a PEREGRINE. 
At Percha Dam State Park CB and NH on  October 17 saw a CATBIRD.   
ChB on  October 27 in the north woods had a late immature ZONE- 
TAILED  HAWK.  RC and WH on October 25 had a  BROWN CREEPER and  
many  GOLDEN-CROWNED KINGLETS. 
. 
In  Taos County: 
ST had a COLLARED DOVE in Taos on October  30. 
. 
In  Valencia County: 
CBa at her home at the Huning Ranch near  Los Lunas had on  
October 28 a BENDIRE’S THRASHER. 
. 
. 
Initials of Observers: 
JB,  Jonathan Batkin;  CBa, Carolyn  Barber;  ChB, Charles Black;   
CB,  Celestyn Brozek;  DC, David  Cleary;  RC, Rebecca Crofton;   
CD,  Carol Davis;  BF, Bernard Foy;  JG, June Galloway;   
DG,  David Griffin;  BG, Bill Groll;  WH, Walter Hansen;   
NH,  Nancy Hetrick;  TH, Tommy  Hines;  JLo, James Lofton;   
LM,  Larry Malone;  PN, Paul Noble;  JO, Jerry Oldenettel;   
JP,  John Parmeter;  CP. Cathy  Pasterczyk;  CR, Chris Rustay;   
JSa,  Jeff Sanchez;  MS, Marcy Scott;  ST, Stephanie Thomas;   
SW,  Steve West;  WW, Bill Wittman;  RY, Rob Yaksich;   
and  JZ, Jimmy Zabriskie;   
. 
. 
Field  Trips:  
. 
Central Audubon in Albuquerque has Thursday field trips.   
All  phone numbers begin with 505.  On  November 12 to the  
Cedro  Campground and Sabino Canyon south of Tijeras with the  
Boettchers, 281-6726.  On November 19 a hike in Rinconada  
Canyon  in the Petroglyph NM with Rebecca Gracey,  
242-3821.  No trip is  planned for Thanksgiving. 
. 
The  Las Vegas Refuge will have trips on Sundays in November  
to the  back road of the refuge (usually closed) with programs.   
On  November 8 Raymond VanBuskirk will discuss “Birds of  
Northern NM.”  On  November 15 “Duck Butts” with Rob Yaksich,  
and on  November 22 “South from Alaska with the Roving Ruges”  
a  travel show with a local family. 
. 
The  Festival of Cranes at Bosque del Apache Refuge will be  
November 17-22 this fall. 
. 
The  Rio Grande Nature Center has morning bird walks on Sunday  
and  Saturday mornings at 9 a.m. 
. 
-End  Transcript_[1]_ (aoldb://mail/write/template.htm#_ftn1)  
…. 

 
____________________________________

_[1]_ (aoldb://mail/write/template.htm#_ftnref1)  
Subject: Odd N. Flicker at Agua Caliente Park, Tucson
From: Diane Touret <dctouret AT COMCAST.NET>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 05:13:25 -0700
On Monday I stopped briefly at Agua Caliente Park in NE Tucson. The windy 
conditions made birding difficult, but I did notice an odd, possibly hybrid 
Yellow-shafted X Red-Shafted Northern Flicker. The bird had a Yellow-shafted 
Flicker's head pattern with brownish cheeks and a black malar and a yellow 
upper underwing (at least under the "shoulder"). The flight feathers and 
undertail, however, appeared red, and when the bird flew, the underwing 
looked orange. Also noted at the park were about a dozen Cedar Waxwings and 
a calling, but invisible, N. Beardless-Tyrannulet.   Diane Touret 
(Tucson,AZ) 
Subject: SE AZ: Patagonia Rufous-backed Robin, San Rafael Grasslands
From: Moez Ali <moezali15 AT GMAIL.COM>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 00:33:58 -0700
Hi Birders,

Thanks to Mark Stevenson for the timely update.

Ex-Tucson and current Atlanta birder friend Stephen Barlow and I had
great looks of a Rufous-backed Robin at the Spirit Tree Inn along
Harshaw Road in Patagonia late this morning. It was first spotted in
the pyrracantha tree in the courtyard and also spent time foraging on
the ground behind the air conditioning unit along the wooden fence.
Excellent looks were had as it perched in leafless trees before
returning to dine on more berries with an American Robin, Cedar
Waxwings, Red-naped Sapsuckers, Western Bluebirds and Pyrrhuloxias. I
obtained some photos for the AZFO gallery.

In the San Rafael Grasslands, the large water tank just southeast of
the main intersection of Forest Roads 765, 214 and 58 had the most
action with a flock of Chestnut-collared Longspurs, a Baird's Sparrow,
a female Bufflehead and assortment of sparrows coming in. Further east
on FR 58 we had a very pale prairie Merlin, a Sharp-shinned Hawk and 2
White-tailed Kites.

Moez Ali
Tucson/Kenya
Subject: Boyce Thompson Arboretum, AZ--Rufous-backed Robin still present
From: Gary Nunn <garybnunn AT GMAIL.COM>
Date: Thu, 5 Nov 2009 03:15:19 +0000
Midweek and the arboretum is nearly deserted, of people. As a result birds  
are showing well and sitting beside a berry-laden tree or two reveals all  
kinds of action.

RUFOUS-BACKED ROBIN continues today (Wednesday October 4th, 2009) at around  
3:30 pm in the Rose Garden. There is a small tree in the northwest corner  
of the rose garden smothered in deep purple oblong berries with many winter  
visitor and resident birds feeding together in this tree, such as the  
following:

Rufous-backed Robin - 1
American Robin - 5 (+ a few more I could hear calling in the distance), at  
one point 3 birds were shoulder-to-shoulder in the tree gulping down berries
Hermit Thrush - 3
Cedar Waxwing - 20
Phainopepla - 10

Further down the trail at the Herb Garden a Green-tailed Towhee amongst  
Abert's Towhee and many White-crowned Sparrow. Numbers of Dark-eyed Junco  
and WC Sparrows are increasing considerably.

Netleaf Hackberry and exotic berry "trees" seem the best hotspots. The  
Chinese Pistachios still have fruit present, but many bird species seem to  
have shifted attention to the smaller trees with tastier fare.

Gary Nunn,
Ahwatukee, AZ